Constellations
The Urth list — 4 messages, 4 voices, 25 Mar 1999
https://urth.darkrealm.vip/thread/urth/1451

Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright
in each message remains with the person who wrote it.

Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original
archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than
retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.

==============================================================================

m.driussi — 25 Mar 1999, 21:23

Mitchell A. Bailey,

CONSTELLATIONS OF URTH'S SOUTHERN HEMISPHERE
Amphisbaena (III, ch. 14)
the Cross (III, ch. 18; V, ch. 49)
the Crotali (V, ch. 49)
the Eight (IV, ch. 25)
Great Bull (III, ch. 18; IV, ch. 23)
Hydra (III, ch. 18)
Ihuaivulu (II, ch. 29)
Little Wolf (III, ch. 18)
Peryton (III, ch. 13)
Septentrion (I, ch. 18)
Swan (IV, ch. 23)
Unicorn (III, ch. 18)
Wolf (III, ch. 18)

=mantis=

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mitchell A. Bailey — 30 Mar 1999, 20:40
  follows, by subject match m.driussi

Thanks, mantis. That'll teach me to draft letters before my coffee kicks
in, and to study southern constellations more diligently.

Well, the conclusion is inescapable, given this many examples of
constellations of our time still recognized by Severian, that Urth's sky
as described in BNS is not consistent with the theory that Sev's time
lies in a "far future" millions or tens of millions of years hence.

I notice there's a Bull, but no minotaur. hmmm.

Is your book available retail anywhere? I don't trust the Internet with
my credit card just yet.

m.driussi at genie.com wrote:
...

> CONSTELLATIONS OF URTH'S SOUTHERN HEMISPHERE
> Amphisbaena (III, ch. 14)
> the Cross (III, ch. 18; V, ch. 49)
> the Crotali (V, ch. 49)
> the Eight (IV, ch. 25)
> Great Bull (III, ch. 18; IV, ch. 23)
> Hydra (III, ch. 18)
> Ihuaivulu (II, ch. 29)
> Little Wolf (III, ch. 18)
> Peryton (III, ch. 13)
> Septentrion (I, ch. 18)
> Swan (IV, ch. 23)
> Unicorn (III, ch. 18)
> Wolf (III, ch. 18)
> 
> =mantis=

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Matthew Malthouse — 31 Mar 1999, 13:05
  follows, by subject match Mitchell A. Bailey

> Mitchell A. Bailey wrote:
> 
> Thanks, mantis. That'll teach me to draft letters before my coffee kicks
> in, and to study southern constellations more diligently.
> 
> Well, the conclusion is inescapable, given this many examples of
> constellations of our time still recognized by Severian, that Urth's sky
> as described in BNS is not consistent with the theory that Sev's time
> lies in a "far future" millions or tens of millions of years hence.

I've seen this discussed more than once but remain unhappy with the "sooner
rather than later" conclusion.

How can this be reconciled with:
 1: The mining industry of Saltus
 2: The cliff face Sev decends to Cas' cottage
 3: The 'sharp' peaks of mountains thrust up after those older ones carved
inbto the likenesses of Autarchs?

I can't avoid the conclusion that geological ages have passed since our epoch.
Yet other thing otherwise (which is presumably the function of others. :))

Matthew

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Peter Westlake — 31 Mar 1999, 13:33
  follows, by subject match Matthew Malthouse

> At 13:05 1999-03-31 +0000, Matthew Malthouse wrote:
> Mitchell A. Bailey wrote:

..

> > Well, the conclusion is inescapable, given this many examples of
> > constellations of our time still recognized by Severian, that Urth's sky
> > as described in BNS is not consistent with the theory that Sev's time
> > lies in a "far future" millions or tens of millions of years hence.

> I've seen this discussed more than once but remain unhappy with the "sooner
> rather than later" conclusion.
> 
> How can this be reconciled with:
> 1: The mining industry of Saltus
> 2: The cliff face Sev decends to Cas' cottage
> 3: The 'sharp' peaks of mountains thrust up after those older ones carved
> inbto the likenesses of Autarchs?
> 
> I can't avoid the conclusion that geological ages have passed since our epoch.
> Yet other thing otherwise (which is presumably the function of others. :))

I've wondered about this too. The problem is that the constellations, fauna,
and (arguably) the geography are quite like those of our time. The people
even drink matte still. The only answer I can think of, which is that this
is a different cycle of the universe to our own and that the similarities
are only repetitions and not identities, so that they don't have to occur
at the same time or even at all, is hardly satisfying.

On the subject of geography: I've seen references to a passage where
Vodalus says that the Earth (or its magnetic field) has flipped over,
but I can't find it anywhere. Does anyone have a chapter reference?
It would help bolster my theory about where Gyoll is, how events in
the north-east are visible from Typhon's right eye, and why Severian
keeps getting lost all the time.

SBear.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------