# Carry on Critics *The Urth list — 3 messages, 3 voices, 08 May 1999* > Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright > in each message remains with the person who wrote it. > Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original > archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than > retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact. --- ### Nicholas Gevers *08 May 1999, 16:35* Congratulations to Nigel Price: very interesting and even graceful input on the religious issue. A welcome change from this increasingly rusty topic of the iron men; shouldn't we move on to other threads, like whether Severian's guild cloak is made from tussah, chenille, or silk? On casting for THE BOOK OF THE NEW SUN: Carry On is all very well, but why not look for talent closer to home? With hope that I avoid inflicting any personal injury, I'd like to suggest the following casting, based on known critical attributes of the individuals concerned: SEVERIAN = Michael Andre-Driussi THECLA = Joan Gordon JUTURNA = Alice K. Turner MASTER ULTAN = Jonathan Laidlow ODILO = Nigel Price (because of the "dull video") BALDANDERS = Ori Kowarsky DR. TALOS = Robert Borski FATHER INIRE = Damien Broderick (lurking) CANOG = Patrick O'Leary MASTER ASH = Nick Gevers EREBUS = Peter Wright TZADKIEL = Gene Wolfe Any additions? //-------------------------------------- Nicholas Gevers potto at webmail.co.za --- ### William H. Ansley *08 May 1999, 23:37 · follows Nicholas Gevers* > SEVERIAN = Michael Andre-Driussi > THECLA = Joan Gordon > JUTURNA = Alice K. Turner > MASTER ULTAN = Jonathan Laidlow > ODILO = Nigel Price (because of the "dull video") > BALDANDERS = Ori Kowarsky > DR. TALOS = Robert Borski > FATHER INIRE = Damien Broderick (lurking) > CANOG = Patrick O'Leary > MASTER ASH = Nick Gevers > EREBUS = Peter Wright > TZADKIEL = Gene Wolfe > Any additions? I won't comment on any of the suggestions above; I don't know anyone well enough to know who's going to be pleased or disgruntled. Now who could I be? Hmmmm... Hethor. Babbling fool, deadly assasin. Well, I've got the first part down cold, maybe I can fake the second part. No, hold on. I'll have to wait for the casting of _The Book of the Long Sun_. Patera Remora is just a babbling fool; I can be him! William Ansley --- ### Peter Stephenson *10 May 1999, 08:38 · follows William H. Ansley* > "William H. Ansley" wrote: > Now who could I be? Hmmmm... Hethor. kn i play 2? I'd like to be Hildegrin, because Mr Badger in Wind in the Willows is one of my favourite fictional creations. I've been wondering if it had it in his mind when he wrote the Lake of Eternal Sleep scene --- lots of rushes and backwaters as well as badgers. (There's another for sports journalists, desperately trying to fill pre-superbowl slots with idiotic questions.) corncrake ---