The God & His Man, a note & spoilers
The Urth list — 2 messages, 2 voices, 17 Dec 1999
https://urth.darkrealm.vip/thread/urth/2041

Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright
in each message remains with the person who wrote it.

Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original
archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than
retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.

==============================================================================

Michael Andre-Driussi — 17 Dec 1999, 07:52

I continue to toy with this Urth story (collected in ENDANGERED SPECIES).

It was the first published work to mention Urth, yet is not an extract from
TBOTNS (as two other magazine stories were: "The Tale of the Student and
His Son" and "Fiola's [sic] Tale: the Armiger's Daughter"); nor is it
mentioned in TBOTNS (as is the case with EMPIRES OF FOLIAGE AND FLOWER);
nor is it given a more detailed context or framing ("The Boy Who Hooked the
Sun" is subtitled "a tale from THE BOOK OF WONDERS OF URTH AND SKY," which
helps to fit it into place).

And the story!

Anyway, I mainly wanted to report a finding.  The magic cloak (of
invisibility) in the story is called "Tarnung," which struck me as being a
Lord Dunsany-sounding detail, but a quick search on the Internet shows that
tarnung is German for "cloak," yet it is also used to refer to the painting
patterns on military airplanes (i.e., "camouflage"?).

SPOILERS to follow


The god's name is "Isid Iooo IoooE": this looks an awful lot like the
sacred unspeakable name of the one true Hebrew god (safename "Jehovah";
today's true name "Yahweh"; ancient magical versions include "IAOOUE,"
"IAOUAI,").  Or a Joycean parody of the same name (was it in the nighttown
section of ULYSSES where the text takes on the format of a play, and
character "God" says some windy vowels, continued by character "Dog" who
howls more vowels?  A sense of parody might be in the first name, which
reads "I said," making the whole name a sentance: "I said, `Iooo IoooE.'"
As if to correct bumbling mortals who heard it as "Yaweh."  "I said" also
reminds me of "I am that which I am" or somesuch line attributed to God in
the Old Testament; also "In the beginning was the word," where this name
says something like "I said the Word."

This god is a starship orbiting plant Zed.  ("Zed," as a name for the
letter Z, suggests the last in a sequence.)  Zed has three types of people:
desert dwellers (ala Middle East), jungle dwellers (ala equatorial Africa),
and cold land dwellers (ala Europe).  The recently arrived god has
plans--since he likes the Europeans best, because they are most like him,
he is going to engineer their colonization of the planet.

Hmmm.  That does sound like a criticism of Christian sanction of
colonization.  Chosen people; conquer in my name; God is on our side.
Especially sharp as it traces colonial impulse to the god (which is Yaweh
or a parody), rather than the "mankind uses the name of God to unholy ends"
line of reasoning.

Speaking of authorial context, if this story was written by Michael
Moorcock my interpretation of it would be relatively cut and dry--I have
read enough Moorcock work that is a variation on this theme, so that I
wouldn't give it a second thought.  Elric and Arioch, that sort of thing:
we might call it "Elric's Revenge."  When Moorcock takes a swipe at Big
Religion it is often targeted at Roman Catholicism, but sometimes all of
Christianity.  The name of the god seems rather close to a swipe at the
Jews, which seems uncharacteristic of Moorcock, so I'd transfer this to the
early Christian church (and we're back to Catholic bashing).  (I can't
think of a case where Moorcock writes positively about any religion.)

But because it was written by Gene Wolfe, and because it was published
before TBOTNS, it serves as a sort of overture to TBOTNS.  Which makes it
very interesting to me.

=mantis=

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Jim Jordan — 09 Jan 2000, 17:48
  follows, by subject match Michael Andre-Driussi

> At 07:52 AM 12/17/99 -0700, you wrote:
> 
> 
> The god's name is "Isid Iooo IoooE":

	I'll add a thought, which is probably wrong (almost certainly) but may
spark someone else's thinking. "151D 1000, I.E." Id est, (i.e.,) means
"that is," and means that 151D 1000 exists. He is (claiming)
self-existence, which makes his "death" at the end more interesting.

> this looks an awful lot like the
> sacred unspeakable name of the one true Hebrew god (safename "Jehovah";
> today's true name "Yahweh"; ancient magical versions include "IAOOUE,"
> "IAOUAI,").  Or a Joycean parody of the same name (was it in the nighttown
> section of ULYSSES where the text takes on the format of a play, and
> character "God" says some windy vowels, continued by character "Dog" who
> howls more vowels?  A sense of parody might be in the first name, which
> reads "I said," making the whole name a sentance: "I said, `Iooo IoooE.'"
> As if to correct bumbling mortals who heard it as "Yaweh."  "I said" also
> reminds me of "I am that which I am" or somesuch line attributed to God in
> the Old Testament; also "In the beginning was the word," where this name
> says something like "I said the Word."

	If it's such a parody, then it is a computer PLAYING at being God, and
that will have to be taken into account. This ain't no true God, and no
true image of God, as I show below.

> This god is a starship orbiting plant Zed.  ("Zed," as a name for the
> letter Z, suggests the last in a sequence.)  Zed has three types of people:
> desert dwellers (ala Middle East), jungle dwellers (ala equatorial Africa),
> and cold land dwellers (ala Europe).  The recently arrived god has
> plans--since he likes the Europeans best, because they are most like him,
> he is going to engineer their colonization of the planet.

	Mind - Europeans, and being mental, the computer likes them best.
	Will - high desert people, living by their wills
	Emotion - jungle people

	True humanity needs all three, as Man realizes, so he kills the false god
of the computer.

> Hmmm.  That does sound like a criticism of Christian sanction of
> colonization.  Chosen people; conquer in my name; God is on our side.
> Especially sharp as it traces colonial impulse to the god (which is Yaweh
> or a parody), rather than the "mankind uses the name of God to unholy ends"
> line of reasoning.
> 
> =mantis=

	I think you misread. It is about humanity-in-full, as noted, set out as a
tale that might well be in Severian's book. The Universe is already "old,"
but not as old as it will be in Sev's time. Anyway, the final question is
whether it is better to live as a slave or die, and the answer is that life
is preferable, because where there is life their is hope. 
	The god-computer seals his doom by giving the wrong preference. He is but
a slave, as Man realizes. He is not any true God, or he would recognize the
fullness of the image of God in the three kinds (aspects) of people.
	I suggest a closer link, conceptually, to the scientismists in Lewis's
*That Hideous Strength.* They would destroy humanity in the interest of
abstractions. That is what the computer would do also, and what the
mental-folk of the cold lands wind up doing. 
	The critique is, thus, not of Christianity, but of scientism.
	Finally, FWIW,. If we try to link this story specifically with Blue-Green,
it will have to be a B-G that comes into existence long after it has been
colonized by humans -- but still before Severian (if this story is in the
Brown Book).

Nutria

------------------------------------------------------------------------------