Digest urth.v029.n007
The Urth list — 2 messages, 2 voices, 25 May 2000
https://urth.darkrealm.vip/thread/urth/2271

Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright
in each message remains with the person who wrote it.

Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original
archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than
retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.

==============================================================================

Dave Lebling — 25 May 2000, 20:16

> alga wrote:
> I think we need to
> think about where Vodalus stands with regard to Ascianism--is he really
> a heartfelt ally, or just taking advantage of the fire-power?

> Adam Stephanides wrote:
> I think that the contrast between Urth returning to the stars through its
> own efforts (as Vodalus advocates), and Urth's relying on the help and
> guidance of the Hierodules--and, by analogy, between two different
> theories of salvation--is key to the book

The Autarchy and the Ascians are solutions to the same problem. That is, the
people of Urth went to the stars, brought war and destruction, and were
chastised by the placement of the black hole in the Sun.  The cause is the
inborn nature of humanity ("original sin," perhaps?).  Both the Commonwealth
and Ascia are attempting to keep mankind away from the stars until it is
"perfected" or "cured" or "saved" (or whatever).  Vodalus clearly rejects
this point of view, proposing to recover Urth's empire, presumably with him
at the head of it.

This is all pretty explicitly in the book, aside from whether the black hole
was placed deliberately or it's just a funny coincidence.  We are told all
this by someone (the old Autarch, I _think_) lecturing Sev, in _Citadel_.
It starts with an explanation of why the roads are closed.

I refer again to C. S. Lewis's position, explicated somewhat in _Out of the
Silent Planet_ et seq., that space travel (or possibly only space
colonization) and immortality are sins.  This is a thread not far below the
surface in much of _New Sun_ and even in other works by Wolfe.

       -- Dave Lebling
          (aka vizcacha)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Michael Straight — 26 May 2000, 08:14
  follows, by subject match Dave Lebling

> On Thu, 25 May 2000, Dave Lebling wrote:
> I refer again to C. S. Lewis's position, explicated somewhat in _Out of the
> Silent Planet_ et seq., that space travel (or possibly only space
> colonization) and immortality are sins.  This is a thread not far below the
> surface in much of _New Sun_ and even in other works by Wolfe.

It's a fine point, but he didn't think space travel and immortality are
themselves sins, rather they are a bad idea because they would allow sin
to grow beyond it's current bounds of time (a lifetime) and space (Earth).

-Rostrum

------------------------------------------------------------------------------