# Cerberus (was "The Quiet Ur

*The Urth list — 2 messages, 2 voices, 31 Oct 1997*

<https://urth.darkrealm.vip/thread/urth/241>

> Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright
> in each message remains with the person who wrote it.
> Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original
> archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than
> retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.

---

### Tony Ellis
*31 Oct 1997, 11:01*

                                                                      31/10/97
                                                                      10:16
 Cerberus (was "The Quiet Urth")

>> Nutria wrote:
>> Ok, let's use this as an example of what I mean. You say Satan
>> imagery, I say pun. 666 is "the number of the Beast", rather than
>> specifically the number of Satan, and 666 Saltimbanque St is the
>> House of the Beast: the "Maison du Chien", or House of the Dog.
>> The protagonist's extended family is also a kind of Beast, 
>> the five-headed Cerberus of the title.

> Well, since cerberus is the guardian of hell, I'd say that you cannot
> completely exclude the religious motif. 

             <snip> 

> Wolfe does not positively portray
> anything Christian that I know of in this book, but his pictures of evil
> seem largely to be Biblical and Danteaen.

Hmmm... I have to nitpick here: I would say Danteaen only. Yes,
Dante makes Cerberus the guardian of Christian Hell, but he was
borrowing from Classical (ie Pagan) mythology. Nor was Dante's
Hell a place of "evil" in the conventional sense, but rather a place
of human suffering. I still don't see any Biblical\Christian imagery
in Fifth Head.

> And I think "saltimbanque" means
> "counterfeit."

Interesting! Can anybody confirm that Saltimbanque = counterfeit
for us?

> True versus false humanity is really the theme, I think, of
> the three novellas,

Agreed.

> but Wolfe does associate false humanity with hell,
> anti-christ, a false immortality, sterility, cruelty, etc. Also, a
> whore-house is a traditional image of the counterfeit or false church.

All true, but I'm still not convinced that Wolfe wants us to make
such associations with this particular collection of novellas. If the
whore-house in Fifth Head was supposed to be a false church I
would expect the rest of the story to reflect this, but as far as I
can see it doesn't.

The strongest parallels I can see are with Australian aboriginal culture,
and more specifically with its destruction at the hands of white
settlers. 

---

### Michael Straight
*31 Oct 1997, 09:14 · follows Tony Ellis*

> On 31 Oct 1997, Tony Ellis wrote:
> Nutria wrote:

>> Wolfe does not positively portray
>> anything Christian that I know of in this book, but his pictures of evil
>> seem largely to be Biblical and Danteaen.

> Hmmm... I have to nitpick here: I would say Danteaen only. Yes,
> Dante makes Cerberus the guardian of Christian Hell, but he was
> borrowing from Classical (ie Pagan) mythology. Nor was Dante's
> Hell a place of "evil" in the conventional sense, but rather a place
> of human suffering. 

Just to nitpick your nitpick, in Biblical thought (contrary to Milton and
others), as in Dante, Hell is not the headquarters of "evil" but a place
of suffering.  Satan is not pictured as the ruler of Hell but its most
famous prisoner.
                                            
And since this message has no Wolfe content anyway, I'll continue with the
observation, after reading Cordwainer Smith's "A Planet Named Shayol," 
that where at one time people wrote gory descriptions of Hell with the
purpose of putting a genuine fear of God into people, several modern
science fiction writers have written gory stories about Hell with the
(seemingly intended) effect of making the reader say, "surely this cannot
be." 

ObWolfe: I put off reading "Peace" because it sounded less interesting
than Wolfe's other stuff, but I really enjoyed it, found the ending quite
satisfying, and am finding that it's staying with me as much or more than
any of his other books.

-Rostrum

---