Digest urth.v030.n118
The Urth list — 2 messages, 2 voices, 23 May 2001
https://urth.darkrealm.vip/thread/urth/2661

Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright
in each message remains with the person who wrote it.

Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original
archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than
retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.

==============================================================================

Dan'l Danehy-Oakes — 23 May 2001, 11:43

> Roy wrote:
> ... has anyone else wondered exactly what Wolfe intended with the
> last six words of the story: "a mountain ram winded its horns."? 

I presume it was a reference to the ram's horn or _shofar_ blown 
in the Temple on the High Holy Days (Yom Kippur?). It is generally
agreed (among those who believe in the Fall to begin with) that 
the unfallen animals had characteristics & abilities not present
in the Fallen world -- i.e., the lion & the lamb were at peace,
Eve wasn't surprised to hear a serpent talking, etc., etc. -- so
perhaps in an unfallen world, the ram might blow his own _shofar_ 
without humans needing to kill him? I dunno...

--Dan'l

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Alice Turner — 23 May 2001, 20:34
  follows, by subject match Dan'l Danehy-Oakes

I swore I wasn't going to get into this one, but...sigh.

> "Adam and Lilith never found peace together; for when he wished to lie
> with
> her, she took offence at the recumbent posture he demanded. 'Why must
> I lie
> beneath you?' she asked 'I also was made from dust, and am therefore
> your
> equal.' Because Adam tried to compel her obedience by force, Lilith,
> in a
> rage, uttered the magic name of God, rose into the air and left him."
> 
> We know that Wolfe is familiar with Graves, and I think that Jane
> Doe's
> "Vhas a groose." and "Aw zay, 'ou vhill nawt neffer grawnt offer mee
> agan."
> almost certainly refers to Adam in this Lilith myth.

Roy is right. "I say, you will not never grunt over me again." Double
negative being part of GW's accent-addiction. And I guess she's going
"Yuck!" in the first part, though that's not the tradition, which was
that she got bored always doing it one way, not that she disliked it
altogether.

> On another tack, has anyone else wondered exactly what Wolfe intended
> with
> the last six words of the story: "a mountain ram winded its horns."?

Even if

> Wolfe hadn't been raised in Texas, much less been a former Aggie, he
> has to
> know that no animal blows a horn, much less its own.

This is why I'm outta this. (Or should be.)

> Further perusal of HEBREW MYTHS yields the following wrt the
> fratricide of
> Cain and Abel: Wolfe has a tendency to
> conflate and otherwise rearrange mythological elements to suit
> himself,
> which is what he seems to me to have done in "Copperhead". Thus "Dhoss
> bhoyes, de vhun keels de odder", I still maintain refers to Cain and
> Abel,
> whether or not it also refers to the murdered man and Boone.

Yup.

But (defiantly) it's still a dumb story.

-alga

------------------------------------------------------------------------------