More Musings on Peace
The Urth list — 3 messages, 3 voices, 19 Aug 2002
https://urth.darkrealm.vip/thread/urth/3411

Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright
in each message remains with the person who wrote it.

Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original
archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than
retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.

==============================================================================

StoneOx17 — 19 Aug 2002, 02:30

Hello,

I have a few thoughts inspired by Robert Borski's recent essay on Peace.  I 
don't believe that Weer is the devil, but I do like the idea that uncle 
Julius is the devil.  As Robert pointed out, he has very small feet 
(hooves?).  He also has one shoulder noticeably higher than the other (is 
this another attribute of the devil?).  It also fits well with my theory that 
Julius poisoned Mr. Tilly in order to inherit his carny practice.  

So after a brief interval where he lives with the devil, Weer goes to 
college, graduates, comes back to work for the devil, and eventually inherits 
from the devil.  This can't be good for his soul.  I was reminded of the 
story of the banshee in Peace.  Briefly summarized, Jack and Molly are in 
love, but Molly's father can't stand the thought of his daughter marrying a 
penniless laborer, so he insists that Jack stay in the barn haunted by the 
banshee for a night.  Jack eventually defeats the banshee and marries Molly, 
but because of the banshee, Molly's father dies and Jack is never able to 
consummate his marriage.  I think this story hints at "what went wrong" in 
Weer's life.

After college, the natural time for Weer to consider marrying Margaret Lorn, 
Weer's parents had probably already lost all their money.  (At least, all of 
it they hadn't spent on their years touring Europe and on Olivia's wedding.  
Is there any doubt that they lost their money in the Depression?).  
Margaret's father, Carl, is a pennypincher, and easily might have insisted 
that Weer get a good job before he marry Margaret.  So Weer goes to work at 
the factory, kills someone in the coldhouse prank, loses his chance for 
Margaret, and becomes a virtual slave to uncle Julius.  

Finally, if Julius is the devil, I have to wonder if he conspired with 
Professor Peacock in Olivia's death.  They were good friends when Peacock 
introduced Julius to Olivia, and there is the mysterious letter from Peacock 
to Julius on the President's desk which Weer is unable to read because it's 
nailed down. Did Julius inherit any money from her?  If so, his factory was 
built using money that is triply blood money.  He got it from Mr. Tilly's 
death, from Olivia's death, and from the carny practice, which carries guilt 
at least for Mrs. Tilly's and Rodney's deaths, as well as any ill effects on 
the carnies.

I've run out of speculations for now, which is probably good because they're 
based on less and less textual evidence, so I'll end here.

- Stone Ox

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Michael Andre-Driussi — 19 Aug 2002, 02:59
  follows, by subject match StoneOx17

> Stone Ox wrote:
> So after a brief interval where he lives with the devil, Weer goes to
> college, graduates, comes back to work for the devil, and eventually inherits
> from the devil.  This can't be good for his soul.  I was reminded of the
> story of the banshee in Peace.  Briefly summarized, Jack and Molly are in
> love, but Molly's father can't stand the thought of his daughter marrying a
> penniless laborer, so he insists that Jack stay in the barn haunted by the
> banshee for a night.  Jack eventually defeats the banshee and marries Molly,
> but because of the banshee, Molly's father dies and Jack is never able to
> consummate his marriage.  I think this story hints at "what went wrong" in
> Weer's life.
> 
> After college, the natural time for Weer to consider marrying Margaret Lorn,
> Weer's parents had probably already lost all their money.  (At least, all of
> it they hadn't spent on their years touring Europe and on Olivia's wedding.
> Is there any doubt that they lost their money in the Depression?).
> Margaret's father, Carl, is a pennypincher, and easily might have insisted
> that Weer get a good job before he marry Margaret.  So Weer goes to work at
> the factory, kills someone in the coldhouse prank, loses his chance for
> Margaret, and becomes a virtual slave to uncle Julius.

That is interesting!

Just to be sure I comprehend, a timeline would look like this:


1934 (Weer at 20) Weer buys car as college junior

1935 (Weer at 21) Weer graduates from college; picnic with Margaret ("age
of the bicycle") => engagement with qualifications (we've discussed this
angle before, iirc)

1938 (Weer at 24) Coldhouse prank.

1939 (Weer at 25) the Chinese Garden dream.

Okay, the only problems are "age of the bicycle," which could be fixed by
moving the picnic two years back to 1933; and the date of Olivia's death,
which I haven't placed here (because you did not mention where it goes),
since it complicates matters between Smart and Weer, including Weer's
employment.

> Finally, if Julius is the devil, I have to wonder if he conspired with
> Professor Peacock in Olivia's death.  They were good friends when Peacock
> introduced Julius to Olivia, and there is the mysterious letter from Peacock
> to Julius on the President's desk which Weer is unable to read because it's
> nailed down. Did Julius inherit any money from her?  If so, his factory was
> built using money that is triply blood money.  He got it from Mr. Tilly's
> death, from Olivia's death, and from the carny practice, which carries guilt
> at least for Mrs. Tilly's and Rodney's deaths, as well as any ill effects on
> the carnies.

Right, this goes well with Robert Borski's idea that Weer accused Smart of
killing Olivia, either by turning her into a "monster" or more directly (in
this example, by arranging her murder).  It was this exchange of words (or
whatever happened at Olivia's funeral) which made Smart refuse to talk to
Weer again (and makes the job placement angle so tricky).

=mantis=


Sirius Fiction
booklets on Gene Wolfe, John Crowley
29 copies of "Snake's-hands" until OP!
http://www.siriusfiction.com/

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Roy C. Lackey — 19 Aug 2002, 05:48
  follows, by subject match Michael Andre-Driussi

> mantis quoted and wrote:
> Stone Ox wrote:

> > So after a brief interval where he lives with the devil, Weer goes to
> > college, graduates, comes back to work for the devil, and eventually
> > inherits
> > from the devil.  This can't be good for his soul.  I was reminded of the
> > story of the banshee in Peace.  Briefly summarized, Jack and Molly are in
> > love, but Molly's father can't stand the thought of his daughter marrying
> > a
> > penniless laborer, so he insists that Jack stay in the barn haunted by the
> > banshee for a night.  Jack eventually defeats the banshee and marries
> > Molly,
> > but because of the banshee, Molly's father dies and Jack is never able to
> > consummate his marriage.  I think this story hints at "what went wrong" in
> > Weer's life.
> > 
> > After college, the natural time for Weer to consider marrying Margaret
> > Lorn,
> > Weer's parents had probably already lost all their money.  (At least, all
> > of
> > it they hadn't spent on their years touring Europe and on Olivia's
> > wedding.
> > Is there any doubt that they lost their money in the Depression?).
> > Margaret's father, Carl, is a pennypincher, and easily might have insisted
> > that Weer get a good job before he marry Margaret.  So Weer goes to work
> > at
> > the factory, kills someone in the coldhouse prank, loses his chance for
> > Margaret, and becomes a virtual slave to uncle Julius.

> That is interesting!
> 
> Just to be sure I comprehend, a timeline would look like this:
> 
> 
> 1934 (Weer at 20) Weer buys car as college junior
> 
> 1935 (Weer at 21) Weer graduates from college; picnic with Margaret ("age
> of the bicycle") => engagement with qualifications (we've discussed this
> angle before, iirc)
> 
> 1938 (Weer at 24) Coldhouse prank.
> 
> 1939 (Weer at 25) the Chinese Garden dream.
> 
> Okay, the only problems are "age of the bicycle," which could be fixed by
> moving the picnic two years back to 1933; and the date of Olivia's death,
> which I haven't placed here (because you did not mention where it goes),
> since it complicates matters between Smart and Weer, including Weer's
> employment.

I agree that the "age of the bicycle" and the picnic are linked, but that
happened when Weer and Margaret were in high school (107), not after
college. In Weer's "what went wrong" speech (201), his plans for their
future included that he _would_ inherit, between the ages of twenty and
thirty, his father's estate; his twentieth birthday was still in the future
of those plans. Those plans did not include working for Smart; at that point
he thought he had no need and ,anyway, Smart's plant did not then exist.
Weer should have been in high school from 1928-1932. His father had not yet
suffered the loss of his farm-based wealth to the Depression, so that picnic
probably occurred during Weer's 1st or 2nd year of high school, when he was
14 or 15, which also fits in with the bicycles and virginity angle. Weer was
definitely still living at home with his parents the day of the picnic;
that's when he had the dream of Margaret, the dog boy, and his father (146).

He told the Tilly tale to Margaret on that picnic, which may have turned her
against him (as you have suggested before). Or she may just have lost
interest when the Weers lost their fortune.

-Roy

------------------------------------------------------------------------------