# Another Banggnab? *The Urth list — 3 messages, 2 voices, 17 Dec 2002* > Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright > in each message remains with the person who wrote it. > Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original > archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than > retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact. --- ### James Jordan *17 Dec 2002, 15:49* I'll take a stab at marc's mystery. This is wholly speculative. I don't have a secret communication from Gene, and I don't have evidence from the text. We know that Briah is but one cycle of the overall sequence of Banggnabs. Is it possible that Blue-Green is Urth-Lune in another Banggnab? Is it possible that Silk is the Conciliator of this Banggnab, and that is why he has a link with Severian? Does this account for the similarities and differences between the two? Well, maybe. And Wolfe does think BIG as well as small. Consider the smallness of the commonwealth and the hugeness of the Yesod-Briah universe around it. Viron is also small, but there is a Yesod-Briah universe around it also, but maybe not the same one. Are Neighbors parallel to heiros (or whatever)? Have they gone to their Yesod? Are they the angelic superintendents of this Banggnab? Of course this raises questions, such as how the Whorl made this trip, and whether astral travel back to Urth is time-travel or some kind of parallel-universe travel. Now as for smart cannibal trees, I can see one possibility: The Jungle Garden, which is textually linked with Inire's fish-producing mirror in *Shadow.* The missionary hut is among these trees. Are these smart trees that are being influenced by the missionary? I should look back at these chapters. There is a whole microcosm here, with "waters under the earth" that harbor the dead, etc. Hey! Is this a slice of Silk's Banggnab inside of Severian's Banggnab? Which brings up Inire's mirror. The mirror is a symbol for contact with God/Heaven in the Bible (1 Cor. 13:12). The mirror brings a fish at one point, and shortly thereafter Agia makes the only reference to the Theoanthropos in the whole five Severian books; and it opens to show a cherub to Severian later on. It seems to contact the Super Universe beyond all of Briah and Yesod, the Heaven that is above all Banggnabs. Did the Whorl pass through such a mirror, and enter another Banggnab? Is the underground lake a form of the mirror, leading to the realm of the dead? Consider Inire's mirror as the firmament over the earth, interfacing with what is ultimately above, and the lake as a firmament under it, leading down. Hey! Is Silk's enlightenment the point at which the Whorl passes through the firmament into heaven, and then back into a new Banggnab? Ah, well if Silk et al. have been through the firmament on the way to Blue-green, then they can astrally travel back through it to Urth-lune to the equivalent point in time in the earlier or later Banggnab. Or maybe better, the Whorl only contacted the mirror-firmament slightly, so that only Silk was enlightened, for that was all the Outsider wanted. Then it bounced back into another Banggnab. But since Silk has made this trip once, he can go back to the Urth Banggnab in his astral travels, and take the rest with him. Oh well, this has been fun. If its even partly right, marc, then you OWE IT TO ME to say so. Nutria the Bold Nutria --- ### James Jordan *17 Dec 2002, 16:05 · follows James Jordan* But Nutria, Gene said Typhon was aiming at Blue-Green. Doesn't that mean Bluegreen is in the same Banggnab? Yeah. But maybe Typhon really was aiming at Urth-Lune after the coming flood. He's set the people up to worship a two-headed god. He keeps his second head while he sleeps on the highest mountain he can find, hoping to pass through the coming flood. Then he'll awaken, greet the Whorl, become a god, and rebuild his space empire. Maybe. Meanwhile, Typhon gets killed, so there go his plans. And the Whorl returns to Urth-lune, but in a different Banggnab. Nutria the Secondguesser > At 09:49 AM 12/17/2002, you wrote: > I'll take a stab at marc's mystery. This is wholly speculative. I don't > have a secret communication from Gene, and I don't have evidence from the text. > We know that Briah is but one cycle of the overall sequence of > Banggnabs. > Is it possible that Blue-Green is Urth-Lune in another Banggnab? > Is it possible that Silk is the Conciliator of this Banggnab, and > that is why he has a link with Severian? > Does this account for the similarities and differences between > the two? > Well, maybe. And Wolfe does think BIG as well as small. Consider > the smallness of the commonwealth and the hugeness of the Yesod-Briah > universe around it. Viron is also small, but there is a Yesod-Briah > universe around it also, but maybe not the same one. > Are Neighbors parallel to heiros (or whatever)? Have they gone to > their Yesod? Are they the angelic superintendents of this Banggnab? > Of course this raises questions, such as how the Whorl made this > trip, and whether astral travel back to Urth is time-travel or some kind > of parallel-universe travel. > Now as for smart cannibal trees, I can see one possibility: The > Jungle Garden, which is textually linked with Inire's fish-producing > mirror in *Shadow.* The missionary hut is among these trees. Are these > smart trees that are being influenced by the missionary? > I should look back at these chapters. There is a whole microcosm > here, with "waters under the earth" that harbor the dead, etc. Hey! Is > this a slice of Silk's Banggnab inside of Severian's Banggnab? > Which brings up Inire's mirror. The mirror is a symbol for > contact with God/Heaven in the Bible (1 Cor. 13:12). The mirror brings a > fish at one point, and shortly thereafter Agia makes the only reference > to the Theoanthropos in the whole five Severian books; and it opens to > show a cherub to Severian later on. It seems to contact the Super > Universe beyond all of Briah and Yesod, the Heaven that is above all Banggnabs. > Did the Whorl pass through such a mirror, and enter another Banggnab? > Is the underground lake a form of the mirror, leading to the > realm of the dead? > Consider Inire's mirror as the firmament over the earth, > interfacing with what is ultimately above, and the lake as a firmament > under it, leading down. > Hey! Is Silk's enlightenment the point at which the Whorl passes > through the firmament into heaven, and then back into a new Banggnab? Ah, > well if Silk et al. have been through the firmament on the way to > Blue-green, then they can astrally travel back through it to Urth-lune to > the equivalent point in time in the earlier or later Banggnab. > Or maybe better, the Whorl only contacted the mirror-firmament > slightly, so that only Silk was enlightened, for that was all the > Outsider wanted. Then it bounced back into another Banggnab. But since > Silk has made this trip once, he can go back to the Urth Banggnab in his > astral travels, and take the rest with him. > Oh well, this has been fun. If its even partly right, marc, then > you OWE IT TO ME to say so. > > Nutria the Bold > > Nutria > > > -- --- ### Jerry Friedman *18 Dec 2002, 23:22 · follows James Jordan* > --- James Jordan wrote: > I'll take a stab at marc's mystery. This is wholly speculative. I don't > have a secret communication from Gene, and I don't have evidence from > the text. > We know that Briah is but one cycle of the overall sequence of > Banggnabs. I've wondered about this in connection with the discrepancies between Severian's account of Merryn in New Sun and one of the twins' in Short Sun. (Why doesn't Severian tell us he'd met Merryn before? In RttW he resolves not to tell us the Silkhorn incident, but he could still have said he'd met Merryn before, when he needed help from a witch or something like that.) Is it possible that the Severian in RttW is from another "kalpa"? > Is it possible that Blue-Green is Urth-Lune in another > Banggnab? But now you have "astral" travel between Banggnabs? Well, I guess that's how Wolfe got the manuscripts of these books. [snip lots of other interesting stuff] And now I have to unsubscribe from this list and the other one I'm on so I can devote more time to other things, such as my job. (Oh, right, they're paying me to work!) But thanks to you all for lots of fascinating thoughts! I may stop by to see whether THE SOLUTION to the BotSS has been posted. Jerry Friedman ---