Newbie - a theory and some questions.
The Urth list — 8 messages, 7 voices, 14 Mar 2005
https://urth.darkrealm.vip/thread/urth/4374

Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright
in each message remains with the person who wrote it.

Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original
archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than
retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.

==============================================================================

Andrew Kertesz — 14 Mar 2005, 04:31

Hello everyone,

I’m a student from Australia, and I’ve just discovered this mailing list 
after a holiday well spent on a Gene Wolfe binge: I devoured the BotNS in a 
few days after Christmas, and was – to put it mildly – awed. I promptly 
ordered UotNS, Long Sun, and Short Sun.

At the moment, I’m nearly through a “refresher” re-reading of the BotNS, in 
anticipation of starting UotNS (the rest of the books waiting in a pile on 
my floor), and I’ve come to you with a few questions that have been nagging 
me. In exchange, however, I thought I’d offer a theory that I’ve developed 
during my second reading.

First, my theory – one that revolves around the issue of Agilus’ mask. It’s 
nothing groundbreaking, and forgive me if this one has already been floated, 
but I’m comparatively new to this ;)

We know that the Cacogens are not a single, unified, race – for example, the 
Heirodules Ossipago, Barbatus and Famulimus are described, in Sword of the 
Lictor, as quite different from one annother:

“One, if he had been truly a human being, would have been short and stout. 
The other two were a good head taller than I, as tall as exultants… The 
masks all three wore gave them the faces of refined men of middle age, 
thoughtful and poised; but I was aware that the eyes that looked out through 
the slits in the masks of the two taller figures were larger than human 
eyes, and that the shorter figure had no eyes at all, so that only darkness 
was visible there.”

There are other references in the series which refer to the Cacogens as 
“races from beyond the stars” – none of which I can find on a quick flip 
through.

If we accept that the Cacogens are not identical, or even unified, then why 
not assume that Agilus is a member of another “race” of Cacogen? It is 
possible that he differs from the three Heirodules (in that his disguise is 
more efficient, his motives more opaque, and his nature less trustworthy), 
yet is in other ways, similar to them. Like Ossipago et. al, he wears a 
series of masks (as the "black ribbon" indicates). However, he appears to 
wear his masks in a different fashion…

The Heirodules wear, firstly, a “human” mask, which conceals a monstrous 
mask, which, in turn, conceals their true (super) humanity. On the other 
hand, when Severian fist meets Agilus, the shopkeeper wears a death’s mask, 
which conceals a face identical to Agia’s.

A pattern could be imposed on this:

The Heirodules wear:
1)Human mask
2)Inhuman mask
3)Human face

Agilus wears:
1)Inhuman mask
2)Human mask
3)?

I think that Agilus’ “Agia” face conceals his true, inhuman face – and, in 
this way, he is an inverse of the Heirodules - an anti-Heirodule, if you 
will. In keeping with this, his role in the narrative seems to be a negative 
one, or at least antagonistic.

I don’t know how one could expand on this theory though… Is Agilus openly 
against the New Sun (it seems like his sister is – but is she a Cacogen 
too?) or is he merely a bystander who becomes caught up in the story? I’m 
not sure, but I think the general conceit of the theory is neat, at least.

Ok, so on to my questions:

1)	Is the boatman who sails the Gyoll (he helped rescue Severian from 
drowning in Shadow of the Torturer and, later, ferried Severian to Dorcas’s 
house in Citadel of the Autarch) Jonas? His speech patterns suggest so, as 
do some of his comments – but if so, who is his “niece”, who rides with him 
in Citadel?

2)	Who/what is Erebus? I was never very clear on this.

3)	Is Abia an alien, or was it once an “enhanced” human, like its 
handmaidens and Baldanders?

If any of these are answered in UotNS, Long, or Short, a simple "wait and 
see" is all that is required.

Well, that’s enough for now – I hope my theory is somewhat constructive, and 
that you guys can help me with these niggling questions.

Finally, and most importantly - pleased to meet you!

Sincerely,
Andrew Kertesz

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Dan'l Danehy-Oakes — 14 Mar 2005, 10:20
  in reply to Andrew Kertesz

Welcome to some very good reading.

Regarding the Cacos - one of them is of the same nature as Jonas.

Interesting point about Agilus' mask. Masks in general are a huge
theme in tBotNS (the torturer's uniform includes one...)

Regarding your questions. "Wait and see" is semi-approipriate. I will
see if I can give you spoiler-free answers.

> 1)      Is the boatman who sails the Gyoll (he helped rescue Severian from
> drowning in Shadow of the Torturer and, later, ferried Severian to Dorcas's
> house in Citadel of the Autarch) Jonas? His speech patterns suggest so, as
> do some of his comments — but if so, who is his "niece", who rides with him
> in Citadel?

The speech patterns seem to be generic to sailors in the Urth part of 
this universe.

> 2)      Who/what is Erebus? I was never very clear on this.
> 3)      Is Abia an alien, or was it once an "enhanced" human, like its
> handmaidens and Baldanders?

This is a good example of the kind of thing you have to glerk from
context in Wolfe - he gives you the pieces, but you have to assemble
the puzzle yourself.

Erebus and Abaia are both huge alien(?) beings -- the sort of thing that
Baldanders may become in time - who play chess with humans as
pieces. Erebus lives at the South Pole, near the mountain of the same 
name; Abaia lives under the sea. There is a third, if you can catch the
name.

Welcome aboard.

--Dan'l (Blattid)

  --
  You probably do not want to know what that odor is.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

maru — 14 Mar 2005, 14:40
  in reply to Dan'l Danehy-Oakes

> Dan'l Danehy-Oakes wrote:
> This is a good example of the kind of thing you have to glerk from
> 
> context in Wolfe - he gives you the pieces, but you have to assemble
> the puzzle yourself.
> 
> Erebus and Abaia are both huge alien(?) beings -- the sort of thing that
> Baldanders may become in time - who play chess with humans as
> pieces. Erebus lives at the South Pole, near the mountain of the same 
> name; Abaia lives under the sea. There is a third, if you can catch the
> name.
> 
> Welcome aboard.
> 
> --Dan'l (Blattid)
>  

What makes you think Erebus/Abaia are aliens (cacogens)?
Is it just because Baldanders seems to be like them, and non-human
(which would explain why the cacogens take such trouble to teach him.)?

That said,: There was a third!?!

~Maru
Looks like I'll be re-reading it; makes me glad I dropped the money and 
actually bought'em,
as is not my wont.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Chris — 14 Mar 2005, 15:21
  in reply to maru

Abaia, Erebus & co. were described as aliens, if you believe the origin 
story of where they came from. I am not 100% sure it is accurate to call 
them "cacogens", because "cacogens" seems to have a more specific 
connotation than simply any and all types of alien.

Alien or not, at Baldander's castle mention is also made of the life cycle 
of his people/species/type (which is where the connection is made to 
Abaia/Erebus/etc), which does distinguish them as non-human at the very 
least.

I remember that there was a third, but I cannot remember its name.

> Dan'l Danehy-Oakes wrote:

> > This is a good example of the kind of thing you have to glerk from
> > 
> > context in Wolfe - he gives you the pieces, but you have to assemble
> > the puzzle yourself.
> > 
> > Erebus and Abaia are both huge alien(?) beings -- the sort of thing that
> > Baldanders may become in time - who play chess with humans as
> > pieces. Erebus lives at the South Pole, near the mountain of the same 
> > name; Abaia lives under the sea. There is a third, if you can catch the
> > name.
> > 
> > Welcome aboard.
> > 
> > --Dan'l (Blattid)

> What makes you think Erebus/Abaia are aliens (cacogens)?
> Is it just because Baldanders seems to be like them, and non-human
> (which would explain why the cacogens take such trouble to teach him.)?
> 
> That said,: There was a third!?!
> 
> ~Maru
> Looks like I'll be re-reading it; makes me glad I dropped the money and 
> actually bought'em,
> as is not my wont.
> _______________________________________________

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Samuel L. — 14 Mar 2005, 15:45
  in reply to Chris

Scylla?

> On Mon, 14 Mar 2005 23:21:36 +0000, Chris <rasputin_ at hotmail.com> wrote:
> Abaia, Erebus & co. were described as aliens, if you believe the origin
> story of where they came from. I am not 100% sure it is accurate to call
> them "cacogens", because "cacogens" seems to have a more specific
> connotation than simply any and all types of alien.
> 
> Alien or not, at Baldander's castle mention is also made of the life cycle
> of his people/species/type (which is where the connection is made to
> Abaia/Erebus/etc), which does distinguish them as non-human at the very
> least.
> 
> I remember that there was a third, but I cannot remember its name.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

mournings glory — 14 Mar 2005, 16:35
  in reply to Dan'l Danehy-Oakes

> Erebus and Abaia are both huge alien(?) beings -- the sort of thing that
> Baldanders may become in time - who play chess with humans as
> pieces. Erebus lives at the South Pole, near the mountain of the same
> name; Abaia lives under the sea. There is a third, if you can catch the
> name.

There is actually a fourth: Arioch (IV, chap 1). And Blaithmaic's book in 
the library of the Citadel, _Lives of the Seventeen Megatherians_, suggests 
there may be as many as 13 more--all (or mostly?) unnamed.

msg

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

James Wynn — 14 Mar 2005, 16:53
  in reply to Chris

> Alien or not, at Baldander's castle mention is also made of the life cycle
> of his people/species/type (which is where the connection is made to 
> Abaia/Erebus/etc), which does distinguish them as non-human at the very 
> least.

Well, "non-human" *now* perhaps. I understood that Baldanders' growth was 
technologically induced in a bid for eternal life.

Welcome, Andrew. Perhaps you will be the one to finally straighten all this 
out.

~ Crush 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

maru — 19 Mar 2005, 20:57
  in reply to Andrew Kertesz

> Andrew Kertesz wrote:
> First, my theory — one that revolves around the issue of Agilus? mask. 
> It’s nothing groundbreaking, and forgive me if this one has already 
> been floated, but I’m comparatively new to this ;)
> 
> We know that the Cacogens are not a single, unified, race — for 
> example, the Heirodules Ossipago, Barbatus and Famulimus are 
> described, in Sword of the Lictor, as quite different from one annother:
> 
> “One, if he had been truly a human being, would have been short and 
> stout. The other two were a good head taller than I, as tall as 
> exultants” The masks all three wore gave them the faces of refined men 
> of middle age, thoughtful and poised; but I was aware that the eyes 
> that looked out through the slits in the masks of the two taller 
> figures were larger than human eyes, and that the shorter figure had 
> no eyes at all, so that only darkness was visible there.
> 
> There are other references in the series which refer to the Cacogens 
> as “races from beyond the stars” — none of which I can find on a quick 
> flip through.
> 
> If we accept that the Cacogens are not identical, or even unified, 
> then why not assume that Agilus is a member of another “race” of 
> Cacogen? It is possible that he differs from the three Heirodules (in 
> that his disguise is more efficient, his motives more opaque, and his 
> nature less trustworthy), yet is in other ways, similar to them. Like 
> Ossipago et. al, he wears a series of masks (as the "black ribbon" 
> indicates). However, he appears to wear his masks in a different fashion?
> 
> The Heirodules wear, firstly, a “human” mask, which conceals a 
> monstrous mask, which, in turn, conceals their true (super) humanity. 
> On the other hand, when Severian fist meets Agilus, the shopkeeper 
> wears a death’s mask, which conceals a face identical to Agia’s.
> 
> A pattern could be imposed on this:
> 
> The Heirodules wear:
> 1)Human mask
> 2)Inhuman mask
> 3)Human face
> 
> Agilus wears:
> 1)Inhuman mask
> 2)Human mask
> 3)?
> 
> I think that Agilus? ?Agia? face conceals his true, inhuman face ? 
> and, in this way, he is an inverse of the Heirodules - an 
> anti-Heirodule, if you will. In keeping with this, his role in the 
> narrative seems to be a negative one, or at least antagonistic.
> 
> I don’t know how one could expand on this theory though? Is Agilus 
> openly against the New Sun (it seems like his sister is — but is she a 
> Cacogen too?) or is he merely a bystander who becomes caught up in the 
> story? I’m not sure, but I think the general conceit of the theory is 
> neat, at least.

Sounds like Raynor would like to chat wi' you : )

But seriously, if Agilus was a cacogen, and one that was opposed to the 
New Sun, wouldn't he be
associated with Typhon and the magicians with claws
(Side note: I actually own a pair of those weapons.
Wolfe doesn't mention that their primary use these days is for climbing 
vertically (usually paired with
a set for the feet as well.) not self-defense, though I understand the 
ninja made heavy use of shuko.
This suggests an interesting thought to me: the cosmogony is up=good, 
and the magicians seek
to gain power by putting the New Sun, thereby rising. Or climbing. Hmm....
But if you want to use them, you really gotta add padding. End digression.)
, since if he is indeed a anti-cacogen (insofar only as his goals are 
different. I don't think he would be a
creature even lower than Urthians. Doesn't seem fitting somehow) his 
goals would coincide with
the two previously mentioned groups.

Further, one would expect his execution by Severian to be fraught with 
significance, or at least far deeper
than meets the eye. Now, I'm not particularly sharp in that arena (I am 
told I missed essentially everything
in the BotLS) so take my words with some salt, but I saw no more than 
the usual human drama in it.

Finally, if your ideas hold up, Agilus would almost have to be a 
loathsome creature below humanity and far
below the cacogens we see directly, since the cacogens original mask 
though a lie, ironically turns out to
be the truth; by analogy, the 'inhuman' mask of Agilus would 'ironically 
turns out to be the truth', making hime
inhuman.

~Maru

------------------------------------------------------------------------------