James Wynn20 May 2005, 12:25
↳ in reply to Alexander Wallis
Okay. I'll take this one on. For starters, a re-reading is probably in order. It is often said that Wolfe cannot be read, only re-read.
Alexander Wallis said:
1 quoted line
However I have to admit I got a little lost not long after Severian's return to Urth. In fact the last couple of chapters were pretty much lost on me and I don't understand the significance of Apu-Punchau.
Hmmm...well, if you only failed to see the significance of Apu-Punchau, then there is probably a lot of which you misunderstood the significance and didn't realize it.
There are possibly many points to the AP story, such as the nature of prophecy to an Increate who exists outside of time. The nature of identity of the Christian Messiah (vis a vis Dionysus, Hari Krishna, and Mithra) in that Conciliator IS, is LIKE, and is NOT the same as, Apu-Punchau who was an earlier Conciliator when Urth's Sun was young and hale. I'm sure there are other significances.
1 quoted line
From reading your discussions it seems clear there is no definitive explanation of anything about these books.
See? You are picking this up fast.
2 quoted lines
However I'd like to know what
long term Wolfe readers understand by the concluding events in Urth of the New Sun. Specifically was Severian also the bringer of the old Sun?
In what way do you mean that? The Old Sun is damaged by having a black hole in it. Severian brings "The White Fountain", a reverse black hole to heal it.
2 quoted lines
Was Apu-Punchau
merely Severian in an earlier time, or were they both representations of the same principle (as per the anima discussion)?
Well, let me ask you: Who was the Severian who "nearly" drowned in the Gyol? Who was the Severian that fell down that shaft in UotNS?
~ Crush
Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright in each message remains with the person who wrote it. Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.