Ooh! This sounds like a fun Fermi problem.*
We can use the Birthday Paradox to find out. One result in the Wikipedia article is that
'This is a result of the good approximation that an event with 1 in k probability will have a 50% chance of occurring at least once if it is repeated k ln 2 times.'**
Let's assume you park once a day averaged over your lifetime and you start driving at age 20; your life expectancy would be somewhere around >70, so that's 50 years * 365 days per year, so that's 18250 days, and one parking per day so 18250 parking incidents where you could've noticed such a thing.
Let's assume that there was a 50% chance of you ever seeing such an occurrence (you were somewhat lucky), so that we can say '18250 = k * ln 2'. Then, '18250 / ln 2 = k', and a calculator says that k = 26329 and so the odds are 1 in 26,329.
Of course, this is only the odds of
you seeing someone with a Cthulhu sticker parked in front of you. You observe a Silk is Calde sticker every day, after all. For the rest of us, the odds are even worse since our observation would have to both stickers. So the odds for us is probably more like 1/26,329 * 1/26,329. (For you, it's more like 1 * 1/26,329 as explained previously.)
In an aside, there are 254 million cars in the US. (
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passenger_vehicles_in_the_United_States)
*
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_problem
**
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birthday_paradox#Approximation_of_number_of_people