Talos play as the Short Sun

Larry Miller27 Nov 2012, 01:54

Just reading the the Claw thread I took note of Lees comparison of the name Jahi and Jahlee and wondered if there were any correspondences between the Short Sun story and Talos' play. Could Silk have returned to Urth after the Whorls departure and somehow inspired the original Book with stories of his past? Could the Inhuma Jahlee be the inspiration for Jahi in the play? Is there anyone in the play that could be Silk?

12 quoted lines · 1–2 deep

On Mon, Nov 26, 2012 at 10:51 AM, Lee Berman <severiansola at hotmail.com>wrote:

David Stockhoff: Typhon was certainly THE Serpent, but was he A serpent? Is Severian something like the thorn of the field raised up to the degree that Typhon/Satan is a raised-up serpent of the field? i.e., the better counterpart to him? Are the two of them hammer and anvil in shaping a more morally advanced humanity? I'm just spitballing.

Spitballing may be what we are limited to in a story which jumbles Theseus with the Monitor and Merrimac and Mowgli with Romulus and Remus and Squanto. As I see it, mythological Typhon was a potentially world-destroying mandragon, partially composed of snakes. His wife was Echidna, a cave-dwelling snake woman whose myth is in a direct line to the Roman Cumaean Sybil who is known as one of the earliest harbingers of Jesus Christ. This all gets jumbled into BotNS, tossing Alexander and others into the mix as well. FWIW, in Long Sun, Quetzal the inhumi, tells Remora (fishy stowaway, also an inhumi?) this story:

"A-man and Wo-man like rabbits in a garden. The--what do you call them?...The cobra persuaded Wo-man to eat fruit from his tree, miraculous fruit whose taste conferred wisdom...It is all in the Writings. Or nearly all. A god called Ah Lah barred Wo-man and her husband from the garden...We seem to have lost sight of Ah Lah, by the way. I can't recall a single sacrifice to him. No one ever asks why the cobra wanted Wo-man to eat his fruit...In order that she would climb this tree, Patera. The man likewise. Their story's not over because they haven't climbed down."

So, in this Eden story we have a plant (tree) and serpent as featured players. Somehow related to the Claw of the Conciliator? This story certainly presages Green, a planet of trees and parasitic reptilian beings. What might Wolfe's cryptic note to Marc, "GREEN is Urth" mean in an Edenic context? Dr. Talos' play also features the Eden story and the serpent appears to be represented by a fanged, busty, red-haired demoness named Jahi. Then in Short Sun we have an inhuma named Jahlee. Somehow it all has to be related but perhaps we were never meant to connect it all in a coherent, structured fashion. Perhaps, as David suggests, intuitive mythological spitballing is all Wolfe intended us to grasp from these connections. _______________________________________________

Lee Berman27 Nov 2012, 15:48

↳ follows, by subject match Larry Miller

2 quoted lines

larry miller: I took note of Lees comparison of the name Jahi and Jahlee and wondered if there were any correspondences between the Short Sun story and Talos' play. Could Silk have returned to Urth after the Whorls departure and somehow inspired the original Book with stories of his past? Could the Inhuma Jahlee be the inspiration for Jahi in the play? Is there anyone in the play that could be Silk?

Well, Silkhorn does astral travel to Urth with Jahlee, where she takes real human form and basically spends all her time copulating. Aside from making the connection of busty redhead Jahlee to Jahi and Jolenta, I'm not sure if there are further connections to Dr. Talos' play established with the astral visits. I do tend to think the question of Severian's sister is answered though. In the play, Meschia, Meschiane and Jahi are persian correspondants to Adam, Eve and Lilith. There are jealousy and vampiric and serpent references that swirl around the Biblical characters as well as the BotNS characters. By bringing Jahlee to Urth, I think he does reinforce the Eden references already established for Green and the Inhumi. By associating Green and Blue to Urth and Ushas via the connection to Dr. Talos' play, Wolfe is telling us something about the Short Sun story and how it relates to human origins and forests and vampires and snakes and flooding. Then there is Wolfe's cryptic note to Marc that "GREEN is Urth!" Perhaps we are not meant to get a concrete, nuts and bolts understanding of what Wolfe is trying to get at. He may be deliberately attempting to install an intuitive, "right at the tip of my tongue" understanding which defies being placed within the constraint of clearly understood wording.

Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright in each message remains with the person who wrote it. Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.