# Neighbor "Horn"

*The Whorl list — 2 messages, 2 voices, 09 Jan 2002*

<https://urth.darkrealm.vip/thread/whorl/1538>

> Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright
> in each message remains with the person who wrote it.
> Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original
> archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than
> retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.

---

### maa32
*09 Jan 2002, 10:23*

I can't sleep.  If my genetic recombination theory is right, Horn went through 
the process of being eaten on Blue when he fell in the vine pit (he fell in a 
tree) and the genetic recombination process that occurred created the neighbor 
who would then identify himself as Horn.  Perhaps the recombination does not 
kill the "animal" part of the hybrid ... but maybe it does and that blue glass 
that Horn picked up had some sort of restorative power that returned him from 
consumption. (HMM What other BLUE GLASS fragment have we seen before with 
restorative powers?)
I have satisfied all your arguments against Blue as Green many times over with 
the plant genetic recombination arguement, especially in light of the emphasis 
on corn genetics and on the release of eggs by the inhumi.  I am going to say 
that the vanished people are not the green men, but are the result of 
recombination with normal people, eventually replacing them as they did all 
the animals.  I will further say that their original city is on Green, and 
that they are the terraformed trees that killed the colonizers there and then 
came to Blue (the city on Green of the vanished people is almost as big as 
Nessus).  They are, in essence, the trees that make up many of the islands of 
blue, humans live on top of them.
That man in the colorless cloak on green still interests me.  Heirax still 
interests me.  I will no longer talk about Blue as Ushas or Green as Lune 
because I have satisfied myself that I have met every complaint against it and 
now Occam demands that the idea that there are two solar systems instead of 
one be thrown out. I'm very proud of myself. I'm very impressed by Wolfe once 
again.
Marc Aramini

---

### matthew.malthouse
*09 Jan 2002, 12:12 · follows maa32*

> On 09/01/2002 10:23:43 maa32 wrote:
>  I will no longer talk about Blue as Ushas or Green as Lune
> because I have satisfied myself that I have met every complaint against it and
> now Occam demands that the idea that there are two solar systems instead of
> one be thrown out. I'm very proud of myself.

Sure.  Chuck the firecracker through the mail box and run away.

You haven't addressed what we know (explicitly, not by assumption or guesswork)
of Typhon/Pas and the origin of the whorl.

In brief:

Typhon was forced back to Urth having lost an empire.  He despises the near
forgotten home of Man and is using it only as as retrenchment from which he
intends to regain what he has lost.

He believes that he can be immortal.

His resources are immesne, but not what were available to him before coming to
earth.  The (for want of a better word) galactic technology is part of what has
been taken from him in his previous defeat.  I make this point because mcuh of
what we see in the Whorl is sophicticated concepts achieved by crude means.

Thus:

Launch the Whorl and place his avatar in command.  Quite thorough measures were
taken to ensure both the obedience and continuity of the internal population and
had not the plan been disrupted there should have been established a colony both
thriving and conditioned to obedience to him and his family.  Ripe to bolster
his recreation of a human empire in space.

As a man anticipating (but not yet having achieved) indefinately long life his
plans are cast into a time scale of hundreds of years - 300 internaly for the
relatavistic Whorl, 1000 externally.  He has no need to send into or attempt
conquest of "the future": he's planning for the now and the next - he fully
intends to experience the future by being it's imortal emperor.

This satisfies:

The internal chronolgy of the Whorl. The contemporanity of Horn's astral travel
and Severian's Nessus. Typhon's motivations.

And does so most elegantly only if the Whorl really travels in space and
Blue/Green are distinct from Urth/Lune.


Matthew

---