Nix X
The Whorl list — 2 messages, 2 voices, 19 Jun 1997
https://urth.darkrealm.vip/thread/whorl/356

Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright
in each message remains with the person who wrote it.

Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original
archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than
retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.

==============================================================================

Alice Turner — 19 Jun 1997, 09:35

I want to object to a creeping assumption in the last few posts, that
Severian is Christian. Wolfe may be [is] Christian, it's possible that the
Short Sun books may move in a Christian direction, like a good deal of the
Cordwainer Smith or C.S. Lewis work, and Severian himself may be "a form of
the Outsider," but that doesn't make him a Christian as I understand it. An
avatar of Christ, maybe, which is a little different.

-alga- 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Jim Jordan — 19 Jun 1997, 23:38
  follows, by subject match Alice Turner

> At 09:35 AM 6/19/97 -0400, you wrote:
> 
> [Posted from WHORL, the mailing list for Gene Wolfe's Book of the Long Sun]
> 
> I want to object to a creeping assumption in the last few posts, that
> Severian is Christian. Wolfe may be [is] Christian, it's possible that the
> Short Sun books may move in a Christian direction, like a good deal of the
> Cordwainer Smith or C.S. Lewis work, and Severian himself may be "a form of
> the Outsider," but that doesn't make him a Christian as I understand it. An
> avatar of Christ, maybe, which is a little different.
> 
> -alga- 

Dear Alga,

	I don't want to get into an Alga-Nutria war, but once again I need to
bring in Gene's own statement, to me, that Severian is not a Christ figure
but a Christian figure. That's from the horse's (pardon, wolf's) mouth. 
	Now, the difference I see between the Severian and Silk novels is that we
see Silk's religious trauma directly, while very rarely do we see
Severian's faith in action. I don't recall any point of conversion for
Severian, and he certainly is not a "good" Christian. (Recall how he can't
wait to commit adultery once he gets on The Ship!) Gene's explanation to me
when I asked him about this is that Severian comes from a horrible
background and is trying to overcome it, and at some points either doesn't
know better, or backslides easily. That was the gist of his reply. 
	I have not re-read the Severian series since my interview with Wolfe
(which is available at Paul Duggan's site, though I don't think those
questions are in the interview), and so I cannot point to specific passages
that hint in this direction. 
	Frankly, when I first read the four original Severians, I decided that
this was a closed gnostic universe, and that Severian was an antichrist
(like the clones in Fifth Head). Wolfe was not happy with that at all when
I wrote him about it. That's how the discussion got going. 
	So, Alga, I guess you and I both need to re-read and try to see what we
missed the first time(s).

Nutria

------------------------------------------------------------------------------