Swallow as god
The Whorl list — 2 messages, 2 voices, 20 Apr 2000
https://urth.darkrealm.vip/thread/whorl/824

Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright
in each message remains with the person who wrote it.

Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original
archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than
retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.

==============================================================================

Nicholas Gevers — 20 Apr 2000, 06:01

One of the more problematic passages in THE BOOK OF
THE LONG SUN occurs in Chapter 7 of EXODUS, “The Brown
Mechanics”. Why did Wolfe include such a long
demonstration of the process for manufacturing
taluses, combined with discussion of business ethics
and much besides? Various people have criticised the
passage as boring, extraneous, self-indulgent, etc.
I’d like to venture an explanation for Chapter 7, in
the hope that it’s an original insight.

Existing discussions have focused on Chapter 7’s
expression of Wolfe’s personal background as a
materials engineer (concealed autobiography, Wolfe as
Swallow) and the paradox of how a long technical
disquisition can fail utterly to explain the main
wonder of the taluses, that they are intelligent and
capable of volition—John Gerlach sees this as part of
the strategy of Science Fantasy, the simultaneous
rendition of the scientific and the magical. Swallow
is really an alchemist, in that sense. And there is of
course the humorous component, the plight of an
unemployed robot…

But valid though these perspectives are, I’d like to
add to them. Consider the topic of discussion in
Chapter 7: loosely, the relationship between Swallow,
the Boss, the Engineer, the Contractor, and his
workers, products, and clients. The chief problem the
passage raises is that of Engineer and Product, or,
just as accurately, that of Creator and his creations.
Swallow manufactures taluses, which Silk describes as
a kind of human being; somehow, Swallow invests raw
materials with life, and is master and seller of these
newly living beings, and this is a morally fraught
situation. But consider further: all of Swallow’s
visitors are created beings in a very specific sense.
Silk and Mucor began as embryos with special latent
talents, and were brought to term at the behest of
powerful men (Tussah, Blood) so that they might
usefully express those talents. Marble is a chem, a
robot, built to serve, which she continues to do as a
vocation. And Oreb is a genetically or otherwise
augmented bird, changed to function apparently as an
oracular medium for gods (the Outsider and Scylla).
Silk, Mucor, Marble, and Oreb are like the taluses;
their discussion with Swallow is a discussion of their
own plights and limitations. For Swallow, read Pas, or
even the Outsider, an articulate stand-in for a
Creator g(G)od; for taluses, read created beings
generally.

In other words, Chapter 7 is a disguised discussion of
the responsibilities of the Creator and the duties of
h(H)is creations. As such, it’s theologically central
to LONG SUN, and has many important implications,
which others may choose to explore…


=====
Nicholas Gevers
Associate Editor, Infinity Plus
(http://www.infinityplus.co.uk)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Patri10629 — 20 Apr 2000, 13:55
  follows, by subject match Nicholas Gevers

Good one, Nick. Well done.

It now makes lots of sense.

Patrick O'Leary

*This is WHORL, for discussion of Gene Wolfe's Book of the Long Sun.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------