# Silk Wrong; Saving the _Whorl_

*The Whorl list — 2 messages, 2 voices, 11 Feb 1997*

<https://urth.darkrealm.vip/thread/whorl/86>

> Exported from an unofficial mirror of a public mailing list. Copyright
> in each message remains with the person who wrote it.
> Email addresses are obscured as `user at host`, the form the original
> archive published. This file was rebuilt from parsed fields rather than
> retained headers, so it is faithful in content but not byte-exact.

---

### David_Lebling
*11 Feb 1997, 09:23*

mantis,

I'll have to do some more research if I'm to come up with a list. I
think what I was referring to was more Silk's habit, whenever anything
happens, of coming up with an immediate and facile explanation.
Sometimes, as you say, he is corrected, or corrects himself, but
sometimes it just goes on by without comment.  One example with
immediate correction is his experience that we've been calling "Pike's
Ghost," where he immediately assumes the black shape is Oreb.

One case that hit me on rereading is Silk's interpretation of his
enlightenment.  It seemed clear to me from the wording and the content
of his vision that his charge from the Outsider was to save the _Whorl_,
but he almost obsessively whittles that down to a charge to save his
manteion.  Only much, much later does he, in an almost surprised way,
decide that saving his manteion means saving the people of the quarter
the manteion serves, which is of course equivalent to saving the
_Whorl_.  The explicit religious aspect of this is obvious; we are all
charged by the Outsider with saving the world, and such saving is to be
accomplished by saving ourselves and our fellow humans, and through them
the world.

In fact, the more I think of it, the more I think that Silk's
explanations are often self-serving in a sense; the same way peoples
responses to religious challenges are often self-serving, and deflect
them from what was really wanted.

Another question (so this won't all be philosophy and ethics): Who saves
the rest of the _Whorl_?  Horn's appendix makes it clear that people
from cities other than Viron made it to Blue. Who got them there? Did
the Outsider enlighten someone in each city? Auk's lander is the first
to leave the _Whorl_. What's happening elsewhere? Why did Tartaros pick
Auk of Viron, of all the Cargo? (That at least has a plausible
explanation.)

     Dave
     (david_lebling at avid.com)

Questions or problems to whorl-owner at lists.best.com

---

### Jim Jordan
*11 Feb 1997, 11:00 · follows David_Lebling*

> At 09:23 AM 2/11/97 -0500, you wrote:
> 
> One case that hit me on rereading is Silk's interpretation of his
> enlightenment.  It seemed clear to me from the wording and the content
> of his vision that his charge from the Outsider was to save the _Whorl_,
> but he almost obsessively whittles that down to a charge to save his
> manteion.  Only much, much later does he, in an almost surprised way,
> decide that saving his manteion means saving the people of the quarter
> the manteion serves, which is of course equivalent to saving the
> _Whorl_.  The explicit religious aspect of this is obvious; we are all
> charged by the Outsider with saving the world, and such saving is to be
> accomplished by saving ourselves and our fellow humans, and through them
> the world.
> 
> In fact, the more I think of it, the more I think that Silk's
> explanations are often self-serving in a sense; the same way peoples
> responses to religious challenges are often self-serving, and deflect
> them from what was really wanted.

>     Dave
>     (david_lebling at avid.com)

	In both the Severian Quintet and in the Long Sun Quartet Wolfe gives us a
central character who is slowly working his way out of a bad beginning. In
Silk's case, it is idolatry. Slowly he comes to understand that the
Outsider is the only real God, and all the rest are false. After that, he
comes to appreciate that even these false gods carry fragments of truth
with them.
	Idolatry is a major interest in many of Wolfe's works, but never more than
here.
	Silk's gradual understanding of the Outsider's command to him is part of
that process of illumination and deliverance from bondage.

James B. Jordan


Questions or problems to whorl-owner at lists.best.com

---