House of Ancestors

Dave Tallman · 26 May 2008, 08:38 · from 2008-May.txt.gz

This is the message as the crawl holds it, before anything here touched it. What the conversation shows has been through ingest: transfer encodings decoded, attachments dropped, quote markers repaired, and the archiver’s ? resolved into quotation marks and dashes. Those repairs are judgements and some of them are wrong, which is what this page is for. Email addresses are obscured here as they are everywhere else on the site, so it is before our repairs rather than byte for byte.

From: davetallman at msn.com (Dave Tallman)
Date: Mon, 26 May 2008 02:38:40 -0600
Subject: (urth) House of Ancestors
Message-ID: <483A7710.1070509 at gmail.com>

Greg Bates wrote:
> 1) Is the "Joe" in the last paragraph of the story actually Joe, or a robot
> created by the Thing? I get this impression from the last sentence of the
> story in which Joe remembers that his girlfriend is pregnant. Earlier on,
> we're told that anyone who enters the Thing gets "a segment" of their
> genetic code read and an extrapolated ancestor as their guide created from
> the DNA sample. So at first, I figured "Joe" is a creation of his unborn
> child's DNA created by the Thing, except that your clone mimics you at the
> time of your conception, ergo Joe wouldn't be talking about getting the nail
> removed from his heart. 
I think the Joe at the end is a real person. At the point they find him 
sitting outside, Bonnie had not yet entered the Thing. Her unborn child 
was not involved, except to give him assurance of continuation. Even if 
he dies in the operation he will live on through his child.
> So now i'm confused again. What's the significance
> of having a protagonist with a nail in his chest anyway? It's clear Wolfe
> never adds a detail for no reason.
>   
Joe wouldn't get an operation because he had a subconscious death-wish. 
He faced and defeated that part of himself. Symbolically, the nail in 
the heart reminds me of images the Sacred Heart of Mary. His female 
ancestors partake of his suffering and are a crucial factor in helping him.

> 2) What's the significance of the paragraph in italics at the beginning? It
> describes two people looking through the fair's telescope (presumably at the
> top globe of the Thing where the climax of the story takes place), one right
> before and one right after the climax. However, isn't the fair supposed to
> be deserted, none of the exhibits open? Are the woman and the man characters
> from the party Joe is with? What the hell does it mean?
>   
These people are looking up at the building from a long way off. I 
picture them as tourists looking through the pay telescopes at the top 
of the Empire State Building.

"For a few seconds a figure stood at one of those holes; then another 
who struggled with him; then both were gone."

Without this line, one might think that everything that happened after 
Joe went into the Thing took place only in his mind. In fact, what seems 
to have happened is a form of timeless information feedback, almost time 
travel.

"He could sense her beside him in the blackness; and unexpectedly, 
overwhelmingly, the certainty came to him that they had waited together 
like this before, and that the sensation he now felt was familiar 
through countless repetitions."

Somehow, what his ancestor robots learn is fed back to him across time. 
Joe contains his ancestors, and these robot copies somehow link to their 
souls. What Joe's "mother" knows was transmitted to him at conception, 
therefore he knows it too. When he gives up his death-wish, that too is 
transmitted back. He now chooses to wait at the entrance instead of 
going in. The others would have said something if they found him 
bloodied. All that happened in the Thing has been undone except for the 
internal change that leads him to ask for the operation. (I'm reminded 
of "Free Live Free" -- have you read this?)

I'm still trying to suspend disbelief about the scale of the Thing. My 
back-of-the-envelope calculations say it would be  taller than the orbit 
of the moon. There are over 200 million base pairs in a typical DNA 
molecule which is part of the human genome. Every atom is represented. 
Wolfe is an engineer, so I'll assume he crunched the numbers better than 
I did for the height. But how much time would it take to prepare 
presentations for all those rooms? How could a world's fair visitor have 
the time to see them all?

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net