[BGSpam]Re: Typhon's nature

David Stockhoff · 14 Oct 2011, 23:28 · from 2011-October.txt.gz

This is the message as the crawl holds it, before anything here touched it. What the conversation shows has been through ingest: transfer encodings decoded, attachments dropped, quote markers repaired, and the archiver’s ? resolved into quotation marks and dashes. Those repairs are judgements and some of them are wrong, which is what this page is for. Email addresses are obscured here as they are everywhere else on the site, so it is before our repairs rather than byte for byte.

From: dstockhoff at verizon.net (David Stockhoff)
Date: Fri, 14 Oct 2011 19:28:40 -0400
Subject: (urth) [BGSpam]Re:  Typhon's nature
In-Reply-To: <470F5296ED694E0CAEF01A845C9CCF22@Rover>
References: <SNT123-W479939E28BC53DD1871664CFE30 at phx.gbl><92596A2A076B4CDCB9153A9CFBC0C8BC@Rover><4E95A59D.8020707 at verizon.net><8A3B6D6FBFF64622A20E9AFAF2ED4D65@Rover><4E95B689.8040108 at verizon.net><9AF7A2A2795B4CC2BA36BF314362BE08@Rover><4E985943.3030203 at verizon.net><543CC319470F4A6FB4920E246DA4B5D0@Rover>
	<4E987F69.1070203 at verizon.net>
	<470F5296ED694E0CAEF01A845C9CCF22@Rover>
Message-ID: <4E98C5A8.9030400 at verizon.net>

On 10/14/2011 6:11 PM, Gerry Quinn wrote:
> *From:* David Stockhoff <mailto:dstockhoff at verizon.net>
> > On 10/14/2011 12:49 PM, Gerry Quinn wrote:
>
> > > > If I ruled worlds with all those tools you list, and then you 
> found out
> > > > I was psionic (without using a psionic helmet), would that not 
> strike
> > > > you as significant?
> >
> > > Not really, if psychic powers are reasonably common.
> >
> > So, emphatically yes (because they are not).
> >
> Aren?t they? Decuman seems to have them. So does Mucor. The Cumaean 
> has. In Typhon?s time, there was a telepathic internet.
In my example, I am not a character living in Briah.
>
> > > > What if I boasted of these powers?
> > > > What if I claimed (or hinted at) them but had none?
> > > I don?t see evidence that Typhon did either of those things.
> > "I sent my thought to far places." Jeff says this may be bombast.
> > However, in the light of what has been mentioned about Urth society
> > before the Whorl, Typhon may have been speaking as he would if his
> > society still existed, which would put a different spin on it. We might
> > say, "I googled it and found 7637542 hits."
> It?s not bombast: what Typhon says is true, there are powers in the 
> sea who would rule. Whatever he did to find out, he did something and 
> it worked. ?I sent my thoughts into far places? is how he explains it 
> to Severian. Probably he used some sort of telepresence system to 
> access the databases, military systems or whatever.
We've been through this. I agree that IF the "telnet" (still working on 
what to call it) survives, then the link between thought and data is 
ready-made.
> > > He does have strong arms and hands, strong enough to dangle Severian
> > > over a cliff. But then again, he took those from Piaton.
> >
> > Which means he does not have them at all.
> Sure he has them!
No, he does not. Rather, he has Piaton.
>
> > > > All these hypotheticals are situations in which the 
> "significance" of
> > > > psionic powers TO THE STORY is quite high. Wolfe has made 
> choices---the
> > > > choices are significant.
> > > I don?t see it. When did he claim to have psychic powers?
> > I thought you said there was no difference! But again: "I sent my
> > thought to far places." Why, do you think, he said that? Why did Wolfe
> > have him say that?
> He?s talking about telepresence, virtualities? Or maybe just alluding 
> to looking at satellite images etc.
But why did he say it LIKE THAT?
>
> > So, then: how can the internet device be "significant to our
> > interpretation of the story."? It presents no challenges, is completely
> > boring, and is never mentioned.
> When did I say it was significant?
You didn't. It isn't. Is it possible to make a point to you that is not 
completely literal?
> It adds colour to our understanding of life in Typhon?s empire, just 
> as elsewhere we learn a little about life in Ascia.
I am sure that is why Wolfe wrote the series: to provide color and 
information, like a white writer in the South after the Civil War.
>
> > I propose that the food Typhon feeds Severian is a ham sandwich. Do you
> > concur?
> A kolpochoerus sandwich is another example of something that is 
> perfectly plausible,,. but for wich we have no evidence one way or the 
> other. All we know is he gave Severian food of some sort. (If I had to 
> guess, I?d say something like the ready meals eaten by Silk and 
> Mamelta on the lander.)
Are you a machine?
>
> > > I don?t think the people in Typhon?s society are tools any more than
> > > people in any tightly controlled society are tools.
> >
> > Not a part of my argument. However, that raises a point: which came
> > first? Were people forced to have implants, or did they have them
> > already and Typhon took advantage?
> Who knows? It would have been convenient for Typhon if they systems 
> were already in use, of course.
Sure. Plot convenience is an author's primary concern.
>
> > > Typhon *was* powerful and unique, but it was not any psychic 
> powers he
> > > had that made him so. Or so I think. Once he ruled Urth, he imposed
> > > his will by a variety of means, but I doubt whether innate mind
> > > control abilities were part of it.
> >
> > But you have no particular reason to say this, except that you dismiss
> > it, and therefore you doubt it, and therefore you dismiss it.
> Direct person to person mind control is a lousy way to rule an empire 
> containing billions of subjects. We hear lots about the methods 
> actually used by Typhon, and they are military, technological, and 
> personality based.
An empire must have many redundant systems. Tree, meet bark.

Are you really going to spend 5 more days trying to prove a negative you 
can't prove?



---
avast! Antivirus: Outbound message clean.
Virus Database (VPS): 111014-1, 10/14/2011
Tested on: 10/14/2011 7:28:41 PM
avast! - copyright (c) 1988-2011 AVAST Software.
http://www.avast.com

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net