Liars, TWHF

Alex David Groce · 17 Nov 1999, 12:57 · from urth-v0028.mbox · original

This is the message as the crawl holds it, before anything here touched it. What the conversation shows has been through ingest: transfer encodings decoded, attachments dropped, quote markers repaired, and the archiver’s ? resolved into quotation marks and dashes. Those repairs are judgements and some of them are wrong, which is what this page is for. Email addresses are obscured here as they are everywhere else on the site, so it is before our repairs rather than byte for byte.

From: Alex David Groce <Alex_Groce at gs246.sp.cs.cmu.edu>
Subject: Re: (urth) Liars, TWHF
Date: Wed, 17 Nov 1999 12:57:18
Message-ID: <urth-v0028-0467 at digest.urth.net>
X-Urthmirror-Source: http://www.urth.net/urth/archives/v0028/0467.shtml
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

(All re: Roy's post)

This interpretation of BOTNS can be supported from the text, with a lot of=20
work, but I strongly disagree with it.  It seems to me that you're seeing s=
malland largely disputable points in Severian's narrative as evidence that=20
(A) Severianis a bald-faced liar and the narrative we have is not merely=20
incomplete, but actually a complete distortion of actual events we can neve=
r,=20
in any way, know, and (B) the cosmic plan outlined (why we should believe i=
n=20
it at all, I'm unsure--why not say Severian is a poor torturer's apprentice=20
who, in a fever, dreams he is a savior of the world?) is in fact the work o=
f=20
what seems almost a fallen angel, or, perhaps, as others have stated some t=
ime
ago on the list, a kind of sneaky  colonization plan by Empire-builders fro=
m=20
Yesod :).

As I argued before, this way lies complete literary solipsism--given that=20
Severian  acknowledges that he lies to other people from time to time (whic=
h=20
strikes me as the admission of a fairly honest narrator) and that his memor=
y=20
is, I would argue, perfect enough that Severian certainly BELIEVES it to be=20
accurate to call it perfect, and given the fact that at least some of the=20
inconsistencies are pointers to the existence of more than one past for
Severian (or more than one Severian, depending on how you look it)--this is=
 a
fairly difficult interpretation to reach.  Ignoring the fact that from exte=
rnal
evidence Wolfe didn't mean BOTNS/Urth to be an ironic examination of a liar=
's
distortion of his past, it seems to break a general Occam's razor of narrat=
ive:
before one interprets a narrator as unreliable to this extreme (willful lyi=
ng,
as opposed to incompleteness or misunderstanding), I think it's best to have
MUCH stronger evidence than what has been given.  Some of the points are
certainly worth bringing up, and I myself have swung over more to thinking =
that
Severian only has a VERY powerful memory, but imperfect, and only believes
himself to have a perfect memory.  However, I think the extrapolation is
unreasonable.

In fact, given this approach, I'm curious--could you elaborate on what you =
see
BOTNS as "about," in this case?  It strikes me that most of the underlying=20
themes I see in it are undercut by this interpretation (which reminds me of=
 the
"Weer is a mass-murderer, and kills EVERYONE in Cassionville" version of=20
PEACE).=20

The statement:
"He is like all those oh-so-dangerous-people who are absolutely convinced t=
hat
they are Right; *they have no scruples* when it comes to establishing what=20
they think is Right--especially when they have the power to impose their=20
beliefs on others."
would seem to be the heart of this conception, but I don't for a moment=20
believe Wolfe meant to make such a cliched idea the heart of his masterpiec=
e. =20
Anyway, I have a feeling Wolfe is, to some extent, one of those=20
"oh-so-dangerous-people who are absolutely convinced that they are Right", =
in
the sense being considered here.  I think the text makes it clear that desp=
ite
the awful price, <the author> thinks that Severian was absolutely right to=20
bring the New Sun's purging floods, and avoid the safe but ultimately dead
future of "Ragnarok."  Typhon's there for contrast, not as a mirror of the
narrator.

(By the way, Tzad's laughter as Small Tzad strikes me as being possibly rel=
ated
to Chesterton's comment that the one thing never heard in the Gospels in
Jesus' laughter, possibly because the humor of God is too awesome for us to
behold.)

"And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free." John 8:32
--
Alex David Groce (agroce+ at cs.cmu.edu)
Ph.D. Student, Carnegie Mellon University - Computer Science Department
8112 Wean Hall (412)-268-3066
http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~agroce

*More Wolfe info & archive of this list at http://www.urth.net/urth/

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net