Thoughts on Undines, and other ramblings

Dan'l Danehy-Oakes · 17 Jun 2002, 16:35 · from urth-v0206.mbox · original
This is the message as the crawl holds it, before anything here touched it. What the conversation shows has been through ingest: transfer encodings decoded, attachments dropped, quote markers repaired, and the archiver’s ? resolved into quotation marks and dashes. Those repairs are judgements and some of them are wrong, which is what this page is for. Email addresses are obscured here as they are everywhere else on the site, so it is before our repairs rather than byte for byte.
From: "Dan'l Danehy-Oakes" <ddanehy at siebel.com>
Subject: RE: (urth) Thoughts on Undines, and other ramblings
Date: Mon, 17 Jun 2002 09:35:04 -0700
Message-ID: <urth-v0206-1257 at digest.urth.net>
X-Urthmirror-Source: http://www.urth.net/urth/archives/v0206/1257.txt.shtml
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

Okay, some of this has been replied-to, but I think perhaps less
clearly than could be desired (given Andrew's follow-up). Andrew
Reeves, then, wrote:


> -[Undines] are basically shaped like homo sapiens that never stop=3D20
> growing and can breathe under water.

The undines, as near as can be told, _are_ homo sapiens -- they are
more advanced cases of the process to which Baldanders has been=3D20
subjecting himself.


> -They've been on Urth since around the time of Typhon, and were =3D
likely
> brought by Scylla (can't remember her human name, and the book's not
> handy) or an associate of hers, as related in Jonas's tale.

Well, I presume that by "they" you mean not the undines themselves but
their masters, Erebus, Scylla, and Abaia (possibly others?).=3D20


> -There appears to be at least one on Blue.

The Mother appears to be of the same race as, at least, the aquatic
Scylla of Urth.

(We need a generic name for these creatures ... "space-going water
monsters" seems a bit not quite the thing, if you know what I mean.
I'll use Scylloids for now. I'm sure one of the clever folk out=3D20
there will have a better name.)


> -They're really into high tech and enslaving humanity (viz. =3D
Baldanders
> and the Ascians).  They are the brains behind the Ascians.

Again, yes, the Scylloids appear to be the brains behind the Group of=3D20
Seventeen which appears to rule Ascia. It is far less clear what the
relationship is between Baldanders and the Scylloids -- he seems to be
in a very real sense a self-made man; and the Hieros seem to deal with
him peacefully, as I suspect they do not with the Scylloidules.


> -They can project their mental presences.

I don't see this as at all clear. How do you mean?

=3D20
> All of the above still leave a whole lot of questions.  The first of
> these is the rather blas=3DE9 attitudes of Silkhorn and Severian near =3D
the
> end of their series when actually meeting a representative of them.
> When Severian meets Juturna underwater (if it's not a dream), he
> basically gives her a tip of the hat and moves on.=3D20

Well, she's saved his life on at least one occasion; what do you=3D20
expect him to do, smite her with Divine Wrath [tm, pat. pending]?

> Later, when Silkhorn projects to Urth, he basically says, "Hey,
> I really dig Seawrack, tell me how to find her."  Now, both of
> these men are Gene Wolfe's attempt to draw saintly, Christian
> figures.  I would think that such figures would have severe
> reservations about the way they dealt with such beings.

Now, the Narrator doesn't encounter an undine, as I recall,=3D20
but Scylla-of-Urth. And what possible reason would he have for=3D20
"severe reservations" (other than fear) in dealing with a being=3D20
which he, a native of the _Whorl_ transplanted to Blue, perceives=3D20
as a goddess? That is, he perceives her (correctly, as I think we
pretty-much-all agree) as being of the same general kind as the
Mother on Blue; and the Mother, he perceives as one of the gods
of Blue, of the Vanished People. Absent a direct revelation that
there is no God but the Outsider -- and, despite Silk's rapture
that contains the line "I know that You are the only god for me,"
neither Silk, Horn, nor the Narrator ever appears to receive such
a revelation -- there is no reason for the Narrator to think of
these beings either as false gods or as intrinsically evil; they
are, to him, perilous only as gods are, necessarily, perilous to
mortals.

For Wolfe, if he is drawing "saintly, Christian figures" is, in=3D20
all cases, drawing "realistic," human and flawed, pictures of such=3D20
figures -- and, what is more, drawing them as very much the products=3D20
of their culture and upbringing. Severian ultimately transcends his=3D20
upbringing as a torturer; Silk at least partially transcends his=3D20
upbringing as a polytheist. Whether the Narrator transcends anything
but himself is unclear to me, at this rather early stage of study.


> I would think that the first thing Severian would do when he realized
> that he has Godlike powers would be to try and find Erebus, Abaia et
> al and finish them for good=3D20

It is not at all clear that Severian's "powers" are _that_ "godlike."
I don't recall any examples of him blasting anything with bolts from=3D20
his fingertips or any such thing. His "powers" seem to be primarily
over himself, and secondarily over time. Could he, perhaps, use the=3D20
latter against Abaia and company? Perhaps, but I'm not at all clear=3D20
how, given their essentially ageless nature.

On the other hand ...=3D20

> But then again, since the Green Man doesn't indicate that Abaia
> and Erebus are a problem (and forms non-Maoist sentences), perhaps
> someone else has.

Indeed, possibly the rackings of the Urth in the passage of the
New Sun has done for them -- consider, if the depth in which=3D20
Abaia lay were suddenly raised-up as a continent, what would be
the effect on Abaia? His rotting corpse would also provide a great
deal of fertilizer ... though it would make the main part of that
continent pretty-much uninhabitable for some time. Perhaps, then,
there are in fact only a few people left on a few islands, and they
have to live there while the corpses of the Scylloids, rather like
that of Ymir, provide the new-risen continents with the stuff of
life, while these corpses deteriorate, their bones become mountains,
and forests and such grow in the new soil. Perhaps: it does seem a
rather Lupine approach, now I think about it ...

> That also brings to mind the whole question of the Commonwealth's =3D
force
> projection capability.  By the age of Severian their stuck at a =3D
fairly
> primitive state, but in the early days of the Autarchy, especially
> around the time of Ymar, they probably had the tech level to go after
> the giants in the water.=3D20

Maybe ... and maybe not; the Scylloids seem to be very advanced beings
indeed. Further, it may not have been as clear at the time of Ymar that =3D

they were a threat as it is by Severian's time.

> The other question of tech level and undines
> is that there seem to be some indication that Urth under Typhon might
> have had the capability of superluminal travel, since there's a =3D
really
> good chance that Scylla went to Blue and brought back the undines.  =3D
If
> that's the case, why would the Whorl move at sublight speeds?  Or am =3D
I
> reading to much into the text?

By the time of Typhon, the culture and technology of Urth is already=3D20
well-advanced in its decadance and decline. Typhon has access to some
FTL transport but not to the technology required to build it.=3D20

--Blattid



--=20
An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net