Arete questions

Andrew Bollen · 23 Jun 2003, 06:21 · from urth-v0306.mbox · original
This is the message as the crawl holds it, before anything here touched it. What the conversation shows has been through ingest: transfer encodings decoded, attachments dropped, quote markers repaired, and the archiver’s ? resolved into quotation marks and dashes. Those repairs are judgements and some of them are wrong, which is what this page is for. Email addresses are obscured here as they are everywhere else on the site, so it is before our repairs rather than byte for byte.
From: "Andrew Bollen" <abollen at internode.on.net>
Subject: (urth) Arete questions
Date: Mon, 23 Jun 2003 16:21:48 +1000
Message-ID: <urth-v0306-3514 at digest.urth.net>
X-Urthmirror-Source: http://www.urth.net/urth/archives/v0306/3514.txt.shtml
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="----=_NextPart_000_0037_01C339A3.8C07CDC0"

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

------=_NextPart_000_0037_01C339A3.8C07CDC0
Content-Type: text/plain;
	charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

1. WTF is it all about??? (joke)

2. The chariot race

I still can't get my head around:

- Is the outcome as Diana wanted it to be, or not? Did she want =
Pausanias to win or lose?=20

- Was her purpose to destroy Pausanias, or to buttress him?

In Ch 6 Artemis says to Latro and Hegesistratus: "My queen must win in =
order that the prince may be destroyed - and thus this queen must not =
win." On the easiest reading, "the prince" =3D Pausanias, "my queen" =3D =
Gorgo and "this queen" =3D queen of the Amazons. So she seems to be =
saying that she wants to destroy Pausanias, presumably via raising him =
too high and inflaming him with hubris etc, in much the same way the =
Spartans plot to destroy Themistocles..

Her reason for wanting him destroyed is presumably bound up with her =
quarrel with Gaia, who has nominated P. her champion in response to the =
pleas of the helots.

In the end, Hegisistratus certainly believes he has failed to deliver on =
his promise to Artemis; his attempts to fix the race so Latro would win =
have failed, and now the goddess will come for him.

But historically, Pausanias gets destroyed anyway. He goes off to take =
Byzantium (as foreshadowed in Pindar's afterword), makes an ass of =
himself, apparently engages in some heavy-duty medizing, is recalled to =
Sparta, successfully defends himself for a while, but then accusations =
of radicalising the helots surface and eventually he has to flees to a =
temple of Athena in Sparta where he is walled up & starved to death, his =
mother laying the first brick.=20

And it seems that Artemis is not displeased with Latro in the end. He =
has found at least some of his old friends, the Phoenicians, as she =
promised would be his reward for winning; and as far as we know they =
will carry him back to Latium where he will find others. She is said to =
have sailed off with them, surely a sign of favor? And why did Pausanias =
let Latro go, as Pindar implies: because he thinks he can recover the =
ship & his treasure later? Or because Diana tells him to?=20

Finally, how exactly would Pausanias winning lead to his destruction? =
Maybe it wouldn't lead to Themistocles' fate, but rather to an outcome =
where P. now untouchably prestigious & powerful  takes the lead of a =
Spartan-led Hellenic league preeempting Athenian ambitions, perhaps =
restores the ancient Spartan monarchy under Persian protection & does =
stuff with the helots in line with Gaia's wishes. Presumably this isn't =
an outcome Artemis would want - but isn't it plausible?

Aaaaaarrrrrggggghhhhhh.

Maybe a resolution of this is to say that Pausanias, despite losing, has =
won great prestige nevertheless, and Latro's actions have delivered =
Diana's desired destruction-road-via-hubris outcome, even if not as she =
had planned. Pindar: " The Spartan regent is cried up for his sagacity =
everywhere ... Pausanias is accounted twice a hero among the =
strategem-loving Greeks."  So she rewards Latro anyway?

3. The position of Gaia.

At the begiining of Mist, she is Latro's implacable enemy who has no =
wish ever to see him again. By the end of Arete, she is almost his =
patron - thinking of his encounters with her as Cybele and as Sphingx, =
and her "loaning" of servants such as Polos, Aglaus etc.=20

What gives? Why the apparent reconciliation? (It reminds me quite a lot =
of the reconciliation I see Silk as mediating with the female powers of =
the ocean in Short Sun, and is equally mysterious.)

In fact, by the end of Arete Latro seems to have achieved the =
seemingly-impossible feat of gaining the favor of *both* Artemis and =
Gaia.

Are we to understand some deep identity between them, despite the =
surface conflict? A hint of this maybe with the victorious chariot: it =
is Cybele's own, but it is made of silver, Artemis' metal (as Pindar =
points out). Hmmmmmm.

Another thing: what's Gaia's position in the chariot race? Presumably it =
should be the opposite to Artemis' - she would want an outcome which =
buttresses Pausanias, given that she is trying to make him king. (She =
knows she might fail in this.) She definitely has some interest in the =
race; she sizes up Latro for the silver chariot, before halping him =
capture the horses of the sun. Why? Why size him up for the silver =
chariot, which he will not be racing? Does she want him to win, or the =
Amazon queen?

Again: Aaaaaaaarrrrrggggggghhhhhh.

4. Aphrodite

In Mist, when they have their little encounter in Kalleos' garden, she =
hynotizes Latro. To do or think or believe what - do we ever find out? =
Why does she not appear again? Is she the goddess who waves to Latro =
from the ethereal upper stands of the stadium when he wins his =
pankration event?

5. Latro's Loyalty to the Great King

Consistently, Latro considers himself to be soldier of the great King, =
even though he obviously can't remember who Xeres is. Why? Is it just =
that his noble Roman nature retains the moral impetus of an oath he once =
took, or is there something else going on? Could this be Aphrodite's =
subliminal command - but why should it be?

-- 
------=_NextPart_000_0037_01C339A3.8C07CDC0
Content-Type: text/html;
	charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.0 Transitional//EN">
<HTML><HEAD>
<META http-equiv=3DContent-Type content=3D"text/html; =
charset=3Diso-8859-1">
<META content=3D"MSHTML 6.00.2800.1106" name=3DGENERATOR>
<STYLE></STYLE>
</HEAD>
<BODY bgColor=3D#ffffff>
1. WTF is it all about??? =
(joke)
 
2. The chariot race
 
I still can't get my head =
around:
 
- Is the outcome as Diana wanted it to =
be, or not?=20
Did she want Pausanias to win or lose? 
 
- Was her purpose to destroy Pausanias, =
or to=20
buttress him?
 
In Ch 6 Artemis says to Latro and=20
Hegesistratus: "My queen must win in order that the prince may be =
destroyed -=20
and thus this queen must not win." On the easiest reading, "the prince" =
=3D=20
Pausanias, "my queen" =3D Gorgo and "this queen" =3D queen of the =
Amazons. So she=20
seems to be saying that she wants to destroy Pausanias, presumably via =
raising=20
him too high and inflaming him with hubris etc, in much the same way the =

Spartans plot to destroy Themistocles..
 
Her reason for wanting him destroyed is =
presumably=20
bound up with her quarrel with Gaia, who has nominated P. her champion =
in=20
response to the pleas of the helots.
 
In the end, Hegisistratus certainly =
believes he has=20
failed to deliver on his promise to Artemis; his attempts to fix the =
race so=20
Latro would win have failed, and now the goddess will come for =
him.
 
But historically, Pausanias gets =
destroyed anyway.=20
He goes off to take Byzantium (as foreshadowed in Pindar's afterword), =
makes an=20
ass of himself, apparently engages in some heavy-duty medizing, is =
recalled to=20
Sparta, successfully defends himself for a while, but then accusations =
of=20
radicalising the helots surface and eventually he has to flees to a =
temple of=20
Athena in Sparta where he is walled up & starved to death, his =
mother laying=20
the first brick. 
 
And it seems that Artemis is not =
displeased=20
with Latro in the end. He has found at least some of his old friends, =
the=20
Phoenicians, as she promised would be his reward for winning; and as far =
as we=20
know they will carry him back to Latium where he will find others. She =
is said=20
to have sailed off with them, surely a sign of favor? And why did =
Pausanias let=20
Latro go, as Pindar implies: because he thinks he can recover the ship =
& his=20
treasure later? Or because Diana tells him to? 
 
Finally, how exactly would Pausanias =
winning lead=20
to his destruction? Maybe it wouldn't lead to Themistocles' fate, but =
rather to=20
an outcome where P. now untouchably prestigious & =
powerful  takes=20
the lead of a Spartan-led Hellenic league preeempting Athenian =
ambitions,=20
perhaps restores the ancient Spartan monarchy under Persian protection =
&=20
does stuff with the helots in line with Gaia's wishes. Presumably this =
isn't an=20
outcome Artemis would want - but isn't it plausible?
 
Aaaaaarrrrrggggghhhhhh.
 
Maybe a resolution of this is to =
say that=20
Pausanias, despite losing, has won great prestige nevertheless, and =
Latro's=20
actions have delivered Diana's desired destruction-road-via-hubris =
outcome, even=20
if not as she had planned. Pindar: " The Spartan regent is cried up for =
his=20
sagacity everywhere ... Pausanias is accounted twice a hero among the=20
strategem-loving Greeks."  So she rewards Latro =
anyway?
 
3. The position of Gaia.
 
At the begiining of Mist, she is =
Latro's implacable=20
enemy who has no wish ever to see him again. By the end of Arete, she is =
almost=20
his patron - thinking of his encounters with her as Cybele and as =
Sphingx, and=20
her "loaning" of servants such as Polos, Aglaus etc. 
 
What gives? Why the apparent =
reconciliation? (It=20
reminds me quite a lot of the reconciliation I see Silk as mediating =
with the=20
female powers of the ocean in Short Sun, and is equally=20
mysterious.)
 
In fact, by the end of Arete Latro =
seems to have=20
achieved the seemingly-impossible feat of gaining the favor of =
*both*=20
Artemis and Gaia.
 
Are we to understand some deep identity =
between=20
them, despite the surface conflict? A hint of this maybe with the =
victorious=20
chariot: it is Cybele's own, but it is made of silver, Artemis' metal =
(as Pindar=20
points out). Hmmmmmm.
 
Another thing: what's Gaia's position =
in the=20
chariot race? Presumably it should be the opposite to Artemis' - she =
would want=20
an outcome which buttresses Pausanias, given that she is trying to make =
him=20
king. (She knows she might fail in this.) She definitely has some =
interest in=20
the race; she sizes up Latro for the silver chariot, before halping him =
capture=20
the horses of the sun. Why? Why size him up for the silver chariot, =
which he=20
will not be racing? Does she want him to win, or the Amazon =
queen?
 
Again: =
Aaaaaaaarrrrrggggggghhhhhh.
 
4. Aphrodite
 
In Mist, when they have their little =
encounter in=20
Kalleos' garden, she hynotizes Latro. To do or think or believe what - =
do we=20
ever find out? Why does she not appear again? Is she the goddess who =
waves to=20
Latro from the ethereal upper stands of the stadium when he wins his =
pankration=20
event?
 
5. Latro's Loyalty to the Great =
King
 
Consistently, Latro considers himself =
to be soldier=20
of the great King, even though he obviously can't remember who Xeres is. =
Why? Is=20
it just that his noble Roman nature retains the moral impetus of an =
oath he=20
once took, or is there something else going on? Could this be =
Aphrodite's=20
subliminal command - but why should it be?</BODY></HTML>

------=_NextPart_000_0037_01C339A3.8C07CDC0--
An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net