Urth Net

Index · 3 messages · 3 voices · 27 Sep 1989

There Are Doors, by Gene WolfeSF-Lovers

Download this conversation
Peter da Silva27 Sep 1989, 02:25as archived
There Are Doors, by Gene Wolfe
Has anyone else read this one (probably, by now... it's out in paper)? Is this a reprint of an early Wolfe, or what? It's very '50s in many of its attitudes, yet it's got what seems to be a commentary on AIDS. It's not a bad book, but it's got more the feel of an early Phillip Jose Farmer than a current Wolfe. Peter da Silva
Chuq Von Rospach27 Sep 1989, 05:00as archived
↳ follows Peter da Silva · by subject
1 quoted line
Has anyone else read this one (probably, by now... it's out in paper)? Is this a reprint of an early Wolfe, or what? It's very '50s in many of its attitudes, yet it's got what seems to be a commentary on AIDS. It's not a bad book, but it's got more the feel of an early Phillip Jose Farmer than a current Wolfe.
No, it's a new book, first publishing in hardcover last year. It seems to be another one of Gene's experiments, similar to Free, Live Free. I couldn't get into it at all, even though I like his writing. Others I know loved it. A few hated it. Chuq Von Rospach
Jeremy Crampton27 Sep 1989, 13:34as archived
↳ follows Chuq Von Rospach · by subject
chuq at Apple.COM (Chuq Von Rospach) says:
3 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
[Peter Da Silva says]: Has anyone else read this one (probably, by now... it's out in paper)? Is this a reprint of an early Wolfe, or what? It's very '50s in many of its attitudes, yet it's got what seems to be a commentary on AIDS. It's not a bad book, but it's got more the feel of an early Philip Jose Farmer than a current Wolfe.
No, it's a new book, first publishing in hardcover last year. It seems to be another one of Gene's experiments, similar to Free, Live Free. I couldn't get into it at all, even though I like his writing. Others I know loved it. A few hated it.
Indeed. It was published as a paperback either this month or last month by Tor (it was their lead item) and originally published in 1988 in hardback as Chuq says. In the next Foundation (46) Gwyneth Jones is going to write a long review on it. In 1985, three years before it was published, Wolfe said about it: ***SPOILERS*** "I have difficulty doing people who are well below my intellectual level. I've set myself this... if I can go and talk about current work, I'm trying to write a novel called There_are_Doors. The hero or central character of this novel is a mentally ill department store clerk. He doesn't read. He isn't intellectual. He watches television. He's not very well socialised, and he's not entirely different from me. But he's different from me in certain ways. And I try to handle him because it's a good exercise for me to try and handle him...He's hard to do. And I'm trying to do it, and it may well flop. But if you're not willing to take chances of failing then you can't push back the borders. "In my story this man is not sub-normal. He's normal, and that's what's wrong with him." Jeremy

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net