Urth Net

Index · 3 messages · 3 voices · 20 Sep – 22 Sep 2000

"And When They Appear"

Download this conversation
Michael Andre-Driussi20 Sep 2000, 09:45originalas archived
"And When They Appear"
2 quoted lines
Adam wrote: I finally got around to reading STRANGE TRAVELLERS, though I'd read a number of the stories in it before. On a first reading, I'd say the major one I'd missed is "And When They Appear." This is one of Wolfe's grimmest stories (which is saying a lot), made more powerful by the matter-of-fact narration and by the deceptive "Christmas story" atmosphere of the first half. (It just struck me that this first half reads a lot like a Bradbury pastiche.)
I, too, thought of Bradbury with this story . . . http://www.english.bham.ac.uk/ultan/st.htm there's not much more than that, but I provide the link anyway. =mantis=
Adam Stephanides20 Sep 2000, 15:33originalas archived
↳ follows Michael Andre-Driussi · by subject
3 quoted lines
Michael Andre-Driussi wrote: I, too, thought of Bradbury with this story . . .
And the link you provide cites "There Will Come Soft Rains." I actually hadn't been thinking of that one; just the idea of a boy meeting a whole bunch of fictional or legendary Christmas figures on Christmas struck me as very Bradbury-like. Of course, if Bradbury had written it, it would have ended very differently (although he did write some dark stuff early in his career). While I'm thinking of it: the man who takes Sherby is referred to several times as "Corporal Charlie" (as he instructs Sherby) but once as "Uncle Charlie." Is this last a typo? --Adam
Tony Ellis22 Sep 2000, 12:40originalas archived
↳ follows Adam Stephanides · by subject
4 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
Adam Stephanides wrote: Michael Andre-Driussi wrote:
I, too, thought of Bradbury with this story . . .
And the link you provide cites "There Will Come Soft Rains." I actually hadn't been thinking of that one;
'And when they appear' does seem to have something of a Bradbury vibe. ‘There Will Come Soft Rains’ is the obvious choice, but even when I was reading the story for the first time I thought of another: 'Jack-in-the-box', collected in 'The Small Assassin'. That too is a story of a boy living in a house that is at once his whole world and his prison. Like House, the boy’s mother wants to keep her little boy from going out into the real world. House uses holograms, she uses lies. Both stories share the sense that the protagonist has to escape this situation in order to be fully alive, that Jack can’t stay in his box forever. Both seem to be, among other things, rite-of-passage stories. They’re about the bittersweet process of growing up and leaving behind the world of childhood with all its pretty lies. Wolfe’s story, as I read that ambiguous ending, seems to be saying that we should take something with us from childhood. Sherby isn’t nice to Santa, he doesn’t want to play let’s-pretend any longer, but he’s left at the end wishing that he had.
Tony Ellis On-line Editor, PC Format magazine 01225 442244 x2349 http://www.pcformat.co.uk

Continues in “And When They Appear” → 4 messages, from 20 Sep 2000

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net