Urth Net

Index · 2 messages · 2 voices · 08 Mar 2010

Wolfe Getting More Christian?

Download this conversation
James Wynn08 Mar 2010, 11:44as archived
Wolfe Getting More Christian?
↰ answers Gwern Branwen · by quotation
1 quoted line
(I'll note in passing the other day I saw a blogger mention that he didn't enjoy recent Wolfe books as much because he felt the Christianity was getting too strong.)
I think the blogger should read MORE of Wolfe's more overtly Christian stories, starting with the old "The Detective of Dreams", in order to develop a thicker skin. In my literary and cinematic SF, I tolerate --mostly with aplomb-- a constant barrage of (what I consider) nonsense regarding anthropologic climate change and (IMO) derangement regarding the last Presidential administration. So I'm not sympathic of someone who gripes about a teensy bit of religious friendliness in order to enjoy the top 5% of SF fiction that Wolfe consistently delivers. I reiterate: We're not talking about proselyzing. We're merely talking about a writer who does not deal with religious characters with cynicism or condesension. AND occassionally you'll see something that could be analogous of a Judeo-Christian doctrine. You didn't link to the post so I'm not sure what works this blogger was thinking of, but I would suppose he was referring to Wizard Knight and Pirate Freedom. Those works seem to have affected some readers the way Neil Gaiman claimed to have been affected when he realized the Christian elements in The Chronicles of Narnia. Frankly, I found the Christianity in WK to have been not that significant. It was there in the conclusion, but (once again) there's a lot more Gnosticism in there, as well as a genuine joy of Norse mythology and errant knight trophes. And the conclusion was certainly rationalized. Pirate Freedom has a priest as a protagonist so what do you want? Naturally, Roman Catholic Wolfe handled this character differently than a non-believer would. Big surprise. J.
Dann Burdette08 Mar 2010, 17:29as archived
↳ follows James Wynn · by subject
While I haven't read the newer books you speak of, I've often felt like Wolfe's religious elements or ideas that appear in his work are head and shoulders above those of his peers. As an entirely non-religious person, I've very rarely found an author that can tackle these things without it feeling totally out of place or obvious (like the aforementioned Chronicles of Narnia), but Wolfe does this very well. -Dann

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net