Urth Net

Index · 1 message · 26 Jan 2011

Mythic Women of BotNS

Download this conversation
Lee Berman26 Jan 2011, 00:48as archived
Mythic Women of BotNS
1 quoted line
Son O' Witz: But Silk isn't the Epitome of Urth, brought as a representative of his entire species to bear the judgement from the Heirodules. Severian IS humanity.
(no worries, I caught your meaning regarding Severian the first time) By this do you mean that by carrying all those memories he is the best representative of humanity? As the autarch implied in speaking of the Ascians:
1 quoted line
"They wish the race to become a single individual,.duplicated...We wish each to carry all the race and its longings within himself. Have you noticed the phial I wear at my neck?..."
I understand the logic Witz. But it is a problem for me. First, the idea of eating dead people is portrayed as "evil" when Vodalus does it. A "satanic eucharist" Wolfe called it. So why is it different when Severian does it with the Autarch? What makes one act holy and the other profane? Second, if representing all humanity in this way was the goal...Why did Severian stop. His memories were hardly a representative of ALL humanity. Shouldn't he have kept eating? Why would he possibly want to stop this holy act. Every time someone in the Commonwealth died, their body should have been brought to Severian. Only after a generation of that would I say he had enough to start representing "ALL" of humanity. Of course he'd also have to go to Ascia. And the Xanthic lands... I supposed it could be argued that Wolfe didn't think that part through. Or that the sample of maids and honey stewards and cooks was sufficient. That just doesn't work for me. For me, there is deception upon deception here. Something deeper is going on.

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net