Urth Net

Index · 1 message · 19 May 2011

Do the Hierogrammates *care* about the Megatherians

← Continued from “do the Hierogrammates *care* about the megatherians?” 146 messages, ending 08 Aug 2011

Download this conversation
Andrew Mason19 May 2011, 22:16as archived
Do the Hierogrammates *care* about the Megatherians
↰ answers David Stockhoff · by quotation
2 quoted lines
David Stockhoff wrote: -I didn't know to take Dr Talos' play seriously the first time I read TBOTNS.
No, I don't think anyone did. But we may wonder whether this represents actual concealment within the world of BOTNS, or whether it's just Wolfe's tendency to make things less clear than they might be (and then be surprised when people don't get it). We know, now, that Dr Talos's play was based on Canog's book, which was based on Severian's own testimony. So he, at least, was not trying to conceal anything. There's also another passage in Urth that bears on this. Apheta says that the people of Urth have a choice between slow death, and death followed by rebirth. Severian says that he has known this since childhood. Gunnie says 'We didn't', but then adds 'In religion - but no one took any notice of that' (or words to that effect). So I think the destructive effect of the New Sun was known, in the sense that it was not deliberately concealed, but, as with many things, people at large took no notice of it. (One might also mention the Conciliator's title of 'Black Sun', and Dorcas's saying she has read some terrible things about him.)

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net