Urth Net

Index · 1 message · 27 Aug 2000

Oh, no, not a Sex Secret! (pronoun problem)Whorl

Download this conversation
akt27 Aug 2000, 22:29originalas archived
Oh, no, not a Sex Secret! (pronoun problem)
I can't believe I'm becoming a Secret sharer in any way. But please have a look at IGJ 81-83. This is the scene where the Secret is actually imparted and Horn does understand it "and what happened almost twenty years ago;" (Krait being about 20, or 21 I'd say). Horn has vision of "wicked women" and "brutal giants" and believes he is sharing Krait's vision as a gift from the Outsider "to share Krait's thoughts, and to see Green's jungle as Krait himself did." "To see it as our blood allowed him to see it." In the next paragraph he says "You feared that jungle, I know; so did I at times." I think the "you" is Sinew. But what on earth is "our" as in blood? Yours and mine, Sinew because I'm your dad? Yours and mine, Krait, because you just took a nibble from me and I'm sort of your dad too? Yours and mine, Outsider? The blood that you, Sinew, and Krait share (re his mother), part of which I contributed genetically (this is ridiculous). It can't possibly be sexual, can it? Twenty years ago? How the hell do they reproduce? Those women and "brutal giants" do seem like part of a primitive fertility rite. I hope I'm not awarded the dreaded Borski prize for this. -alga *This is WHORL, for discussion of Gene Wolfe's Book of the Long Sun.

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net