-
I don't think the New Testament, the Eastern Orthodox, the RCC, or any Protestant demononation teaches that. It is no easy lifelong task to "die daily" or to "put on the whole armo…
01 Dec 2004, 22:37
-
I gotta disagree about "That Hideous Strength". I found it to be an untamed genre busting imagination-orgy of the sort that Wolfe has made his stock and trade. The head of a murde…
01 Dec 2004, 21:15
-
Isn't this a bit like asking of the mystery genre, "who is working in the same vein as Arthur Conan Doyle?" It seems to me that the only current fantasy writers not furthering the…
01 Dec 2004, 18:31
-
Well, I don't believe that in the case of "The Long Sun" (albeit I admit I'm something of an ideological hermit on this count). But if you chose to adopt my radical (but true) view…
01 Dec 2004, 07:34
-
That depends on how much your firstborn would bring. :-) The book is out of print and I'm not selling. A review of the Internet reveals that it cannot be had for less than $225. …
30 Nov 2004, 14:05
-
Crush is giddy about learning a new useful word: ag?on ( P ) Pronunciation Key (gn, -n, ?-gn) n. pl. a?gon?es (-gnz) 1.. A conflict, especially between the protagonist and …
30 Nov 2004, 11:05
-
I haven't read "The Problem of Susan", but I have read "Narnia" several times so I will butt in on only one point. The point about the "lipstick and nylons" was that she turned he…
05 Nov 2004, 15:57
-
I've started it, but (judging for previous Wolfe works) I might want to re-read the whole 2 volumes before saying anything certain. First of the Year sounds good to me. ----- Ori…
04 Nov 2004, 06:08
-
Well, I'm sure you'll fit in around here just fine in spite of that. ;-) ~ Crush…
11 Oct 2004, 20:44
-
Scyetletull, Welcome! Marc Aramini was (to my knowledge) the first and most adamant advocate for this theory (but he does not *exactly* hold it now). The most recent and heated …
10 Oct 2004, 17:24
-
Why not? But if so, the planets Neighbors and Inhumi do not strike me as obvious exemplars of the missionary field that the Short Sun Narrator is supposed to evangelize. We know no…
05 Oct 2004, 10:38
-
Hmmm.. Who will he take the "good news" too? The Neighbors and Inhumi hardly needed whatever theological messages the Short Sun Narrator had to offer. Rather becoming a mere foil…
05 Oct 2004, 10:12
-
Well, it seems from the pictures that he must have read something of it or was given specifics on what to paint. It seems to me that there must be a story there regarding these co…
04 Oct 2004, 16:28
-
Well, life was no picnic on Blue, either. I remember reading "Angela's Ashes" as the author described his parents sitting by the fire clacking their false teeth, and I realized t…
03 Oct 2004, 17:45
-
Which doesn't mean that stopping the story with "Citadel of the Autarch" would have been the best plan. I didn't get idea from Wolfe that his editors wanted an extra novel only t…
30 Sep 2004, 11:34
-
William Ansley: This is absolutely true - especially for the "Book of the Short Sun". So perhaps reading "Fifth Head" just before plowing into the last series could be useful. O…
29 Sep 2004, 13:56
-
New Sun I Castle of the Otter (aka "Castle of Days") "Best of Crank" containing "Empires of Foilage and Flower" NS II-IV "Endangered Species" containing "The Map" and "The Cat" "Ur…
29 Sep 2004, 11:51
-
Well, as Horn said, you saw what you saw, but using the Long Sun as an example, I have come to a much different conclusion. Wolfe takes the stock stereo-types and puts them throug…
09 Sep 2003, 19:16
-
Matthew says: .... ... Well, the concept fits thematically with Typhon's name and identification with Set and all the other serpents that devoured the Sun during an eclipse. So …
09 Sep 2003, 15:45
-
Crush reponds: I'm curious what in your opinion the actual difference would be in the procedure Roy has proposed? Transferring a soul would be something only God could do. Doctors…
07 Sep 2003, 23:08
-
Civet asked: It was in response to Josh telling him that the current discussion (a year ago) was whether Hyacinth was a male chem. Since I suggested that theory, I remember this w…
07 Sep 2003, 13:52
-
Teflon and Blattid agree: oookay. This will surely be good. While both T. and B. are cast from their towers by Severian, how oh how are they the same person? Or do you mean only t…
07 Sep 2003, 03:19
-
Nutria posits: Crush responds: This tact has merit. There are very good thematic reasons which you have not mentioned for Silk to be a son of Typhon and (the original) Echidna. Bu…
06 Sep 2003, 23:16
-
Marc says, Crush responds: I'd forgotten about that. Okay. This is the wierdest puzzle I've come across in the whole LS/SS series. Which is, how is Auk Silk? They evenly divide be…
06 Sep 2003, 06:05
-
Don said: and Roy correctly (qualifiedly) asserted: Crush interjects: Don's pointer and Roy's assertion reminded me of another pointer to Pas as the serpent Ladon: Typhon/Pas is …
05 Sep 2003, 20:31
-
Hmm. Well Typhon "goes to sleep" just after the Old Sun starts to seriously dim and dies for good and all just before Severian becomes Autarch. But who is the other Typhon I couldn…
05 Sep 2003, 18:46
-
I recently took a look a "Shadow and Claw" at the bookstore. The Roche/Drotte confusion is there. Does anyone know whether the Mint/Marble confusion is carried into "Epiphany of th…
04 Sep 2003, 16:45
-
LOL I didn't know it was a caterpiller! Thanks Dan'l. -- Crush…
26 Aug 2003, 19:36
-
Oops that was supposed to go to Marc only. I'm not prepared to defend most of this -- that is, not far beyond what I've done so far -- so please don't get too exhuberant in shooti…
22 Aug 2003, 22:31
-
Marc, This is my third attempt at sending this email. Each time I've said, "oh what's the point" but every time I see your post sitting in my Inbox I start again. Since you have r…
22 Aug 2003, 22:11
-
Does mate' qualify as a stew? We must be satisfied with the soup that is set before us, and not desire to see the bones of the ox out of which it has been boiled. G.W. Dasent, Pop…
21 Aug 2003, 18:21
-
After Crush posted the following: Michael Buice helped well as he could: Crush responds: After stating "I don't want to be obnoxious" you should have said "but I can't help mysel…
20 Aug 2003, 16:12
-
Crush responds: My ability to defend connecting QT with Fr. Inire's Mirrors pretty weak. However, I thought "Quantum Tunneling" sounded promising because it worked so well within t…
20 Aug 2003, 04:16
-
William Ansley said: Crush disagrees (he thinks): Two things: ONE - I'm not sure the seams show between the NS and LS/SS or anywhere else because I'm still not certain (nor do I t…
19 Aug 2003, 04:41
-
Matthew Malthouse wrote: Any requirement for acceleration to or deceleration from that speed would occasion subjective duration for those aboard. Viz the light-huggers of Alastair …
18 Aug 2003, 18:05
-
Civet said: But Crush responds: Probably not much longer than it takes for a writer to find a publisher in today's market. While a lot of lousy books are blocked out of publishin…
14 Aug 2003, 19:19
-
Crush suggested: Crush responds: Well, of course its unlikely. Its a cumbersome theory whose main benefit is that it explains the Whorl's existence in view of the captain's claim …
14 Aug 2003, 12:53
-
Ash quoted: "There is only one ship, the captain says. All the ships we hail between the galaxies or the suns are this ship." Crush responds: Nice attempt. The bit about "only on…
13 Aug 2003, 15:04
-
Nice job, Dan'l. We should all hope to deserve one day to be so immortalized in song. Crush ----- Original Message -----…
06 Aug 2003, 20:37
-
Don said: But we can put that sort of thing aside on this list, act like grown-ups, not rise to bait (real or perceived), set aside extreme profanity, etc. Or if not, take it off-…
30 Jul 2003, 09:31
-
Andrew gives an honest personal opinion (which is what I've noticed people usually do around here, but suddenly some people have gotten very sensitive and simultaneously thick): I …
29 Jul 2003, 13:56
-
Well, all things being equal, I'm in. -- Crush…
26 Jul 2003, 22:53
-
LOL What sort of things do you think people will talk about at the symposium? ;-)…
26 Jul 2003, 20:57
-
Errrr. Josh? Where *do* you live? -- Crush ----- Original Message -----…
26 Jul 2003, 20:18
-
Charles takes Crush to task: Crush responds: Hey Charles, Thanks for the reply. I concur. Sev's and Horn's claims are thematically linked -- Horn does not claim to have a general…
15 Jul 2003, 13:35
-
Blattid asserts: That [all the discrepancies are mistakes on Wolfe's part] strikes me as the least likely hypothesis in general (though it may be correct in any _given_ case). Cru…
11 Jul 2003, 22:02
-
Blattid disagrees: Roy, In most of the (apparent?) contradictions you list, you make an interesting assumption ... you cite Sev talking about an incident, then say that what he say…
11 Jul 2003, 00:50
-
Roy corrects: Recent discussion has asserted that Horn or Silk--or Silkhorn--had a perfect memory, like Severian's. No such claim is made in either the LS or SS books. Crush pipe…
10 Jul 2003, 09:05
-
Bravo, Roy! Excellent detective work. I believe you are right about this, and apparently others suspected it as well (http://www.urth.net/urth/archives/v0028/0443.shtml). You see,…
10 Jul 2003, 07:24
-
Chris asks: On a side note, is anyone using the name "Civet"? I've been fascinated by these little beasties lately. Crush proffers: Since you are interested in civets I'll remind …
10 Jul 2003, 00:58
Urth Net