Yeah I know. I was just angry, which is why I labeled it a rant in forewarning. It sounds like something good might spring from this though. I hope that at least those who know him personally will convey how much he is respected as a writer by everyone on this list. I still don't think much of writing workshops but who knows, maybe that's my loss.
Hey Don,
How much would you pay to hang out with Gene Wolfe for a week and talk about whatever he wanted to talk about? I am really getting away from the workshop concept: since it is not conceivable that we will have enough money to offer any writer a reasonable fee, I want this to be much more fun than it is work for the writer. Few people will turn down an all-expenses paid vacation. If it is actually an attempt to get them to work for free or cheap, many people will resent the attempt and not want to have anything to do with it.
By the way, I am discussing this idea with some of my friends and associates, and the feeling seems to be that it is an idea with some general potential.
Here is what I would like to happen right now: people on this list who would be willing to pay approximately $200 to hang out with Gene Wolfe for a week should sound off. People who are willing to pay approximately $50 to participate in the electronic real-time link that will be set up during each session should also sound off, and would someone who knows Gene Wolfe personally please ask him what he thinks of the idea and pass that on to the list?
Anyone who has any suggestions that do not involve doing something completely different in Chicago or somewhere else should also please speak and not hold their peace.
Or we can return to wrangling over minutiae. That is always an option.
J.
___
Errrr. Josh? Where do you live?
-- Crush
----- Original Message -----
2 quoted lines
From: "Josh Geller" <brunians at brunians.org>
Here is what I would like to happen right now: people on this list who would be willing to pay approximately $200 to hang out with Gene Wolfe for a week should sound off.
Here's a detail that might make this more attractive as a general proposal:
Everything in the sessions will be recorded, transcribed, marketed and (if possible) published, with any profits to be split 50/50 between the author and the entity doing the symposiums.
There are a lot of writers who don't get anything like the respect they deserve because they have been classified as SF writers, and most SF fans don't like them for whatever reason. Wolfe, Crowley and Patricia Anthony are the three that leap to mind; I am sure that there are others.
.
The center of the World, of course.
East San Jose.
But really, this could be done anywhere in the Bay Area.
It's centrally located!
J.
___
9 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
On Sat, 2003-07-26 at 13:18, James Wynn wrote:
Errrr. Josh? Where do you live?
-- Crush
----- Original Message -----
From: "Josh Geller" <brunians at brunians.org>
Here is what I would like to happen right now: people on this list who would be willing to pay approximately $200 to hang out with Gene Wolfe for a week should sound off.
On Saturday, July 26, 2003, at 01:35 PM, Josh Geller wrote:
Hey Don,
How much would you pay to hang out with Gene Wolfe for a week and talk about whatever he wanted to talk about? I am really getting away from the workshop concept: since it is not conceivable that we will have enough money to offer any writer a reasonable fee, I want this to be much more fun than it is work for the writer. Few people will turn down an all-expenses paid vacation. If it is actually an attempt to get them to work for free or cheap, many people will resent the attempt and not want to have anything to do with it.
By the way, I am discussing this idea with some of my friends and associates, and the feeling seems to be that it is an idea with some general potential.
Here is what I would like to happen right now: people on this list who would be willing to pay approximately $200 to hang out with Gene Wolfe for a week should sound off. People who are willing to pay approximately $50 to participate in the electronic real-time link that will be set up during each session should also sound off, and would someone who knows Gene Wolfe personally please ask him what he thinks of the idea and pass that on to the list?
Anyone who has any suggestions that do not involve doing something completely different in Chicago or somewhere else should also please speak and not hold their peace.
Or we can return to wrangling over minutiae. That is always an option.
J.
It's a good idea in theory. I would imagine there would have to be some really strong ground rules to keep Mr. Wolfe from being overwhelmed, and there's the question of where it would be so that the most people could attend. I also have my doubts whether he'd be into it. If those issues are addressed, I'm all for it. Maybe it could be coincided with some event that Mr. Wolfe is interested in attending?
On Saturday, July 26, 2003, at 01:49 PM, Josh Geller wrote:
The center of the World, of course.
East San Jose.
But really, this could be done anywhere in the Bay Area.
It's centrally located!
J.
Don pipes in:
I'm in Santa Cruz. That's two. But this place is mondo expensive, even to visit. Merging this idea with a convention sounds ideal.
On Sat, 2003-07-26 at 13:31, Lisa Schaffer-Doggett wrote:
It's a good idea in theory. I would imagine there would have to be some really strong ground rules to keep Mr. Wolfe from being overwhelmed,
Absolutely.
1 quoted line
and there's the question of where it would be so that the most people could attend.
If I am to have anything to do with it, it will be in the Bay Area, or at least the first one will be.
If someone else wants to do it without me, somewhere else, please do go ahead!
1 quoted line
I also have my doubts whether he'd be into it.
Hopefully at some point we will know. And then I will either start doing some actual work on the project, or I will shut up and go back to shaking my head sadly while y'all argue as to whether Hyacinth was a male chem or whether Gene Wolfe has a perfect memory.
.
On Sat, 2003-07-26 at 13:36, Don wrote:
On Saturday, July 26, 2003, at 01:49 PM, Josh Geller wrote:
The center of the World, of course.
East San Jose.
But really, this could be done anywhere in the Bay Area.
It's centrally located!
I'm in Santa Cruz. That's two. But this place is mondo expensive, even to visit.
I am thinking of ways to make it much less expensive.
Providing one fine meal a day, snacks and beverages will help.
Can't do much about transportation costs, but I do have quite a bit
of floor space in my house, if anyone is coming who is OK with sleeping on people's floors. I would be willing, since we are talking about limiting this to 12 real-time participants, to put up at least some of them. I'd provide breakfast for anyone in the house.
1 quoted line
Merging this idea with a convention sounds ideal.
I tend not to agree.
Perhaps doing this for a weekend, as opposed to a whole week, might be for the best, at least for the first time or two times.
Anyone who does mention this to Gene Wolfe should please ask him to set out every condition that he can think of. Anyone else who can think of suggestions to make something like this perfectly comfortable for the writer and reasonably comfortable for the other participants should also feel free to tell me about it. Send me private email if you don't want to say it on the list.
.
LOL What sort of things do you think people will talk about at the symposium? ;-)
1 quoted line
Hopefully at some point we will know. And then I will either start doing some actual work on the project, or I will shut up and go back to shaking my head sadly while y'all argue as to whether Hyacinth was a male chem or whether Gene Wolfe has a perfect memory.
Whatever Gene Wolfe wants to talk about, is the plan. This event is for the writer more than it is for the other participant, though I hope and expect that they will be finding it worthwhile.
I got really pissed off hearing about how Wolfe was treated. I prefer doing things to talking about things, as a general rule.
J.
___
4 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
On Sat, 2003-07-26 at 13:57, James Wynn wrote:
LOL What sort of things do you think people will talk about at the symposium? ;-)
Hopefully at some point we will know. And then I will either start doing some actual work on the project, or I will shut up and go back to shaking my head sadly while y'all argue as to whether Hyacinth was a male chem or whether Gene Wolfe has a perfect memory.
I would definitely be willing to participate. The timing and location would be important, of course.
9 quoted lines
Here's a detail that might make this more attractive as a general proposal:
Everything in the sessions will be recorded, transcribed, marketed and (if possible) published, with any profits to be split 50/50 between the author and the entity doing the symposiums.
There are a lot of writers who don't get anything like the respect they deserve because they have been classified as SF writers, and most SF fans don't like them for whatever reason. Wolfe, Crowley and Patricia Anthony are the three that leap to mind; I am sure that there are others.
.
--
Assuming Gene Wolfe is interested in doing this, timing is very open and would be arranged for convenience, with (as I mentioned) the writer's convenience coming before the other participant's convenience, though hopefully we would make everybody reasonably happy.
J.
___
14 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
On Sat, 2003-07-26 at 14:32, Chris wrote:
I would definitely be willing to participate. The timing and location would be important, of course.
Here's a detail that might make this more attractive as a general proposal:
Everything in the sessions will be recorded, transcribed, marketed and (if possible) published, with any profits to be split 50/50 between the author and the entity doing the symposiums.
There are a lot of writers who don't get anything like the respect they deserve because they have been classified as SF writers, and most SF fans don't like them for whatever reason. Wolfe, Crowley and Patricia Anthony are the three that leap to mind; I am sure that there are others.
.
--
I would be interested in a Wolfe symposium or even a symposium of Obscure but excellent authors on order of Wolfe and Crowley. This year is bad for me because I'm not sure I could raise the money to travel to San Jose. If this actually does happen, I hope there is a chance of making it an annual event, or perhaps at least every so often type of event. (or maybe we could invite different authors every year?)
Btw, I did not mean to offend Josh by suggesting a con event. I was just trying to make logistics easier. Good luck in your plans.
mimosa
On Sun, 2003-07-27 at 07:40, silk tree wrote:
I would be interested in a Wolfe symposium or even a symposium of Obscure but excellent authors on order of Wolfe and Crowley. This year is bad for me because I'm not sure I could raise the money to travel to San Jose.
I doubt strongly that it will happen this year. If and when I do start doing the actual work on this, I will be asking for input from people who have said that they might want to go. There's no reason not to plan it for the convenience of as many people as possible.
1 quoted line
If this actually does happen, I hope there is a chance of making it an annual event, or perhaps at least every so often type of event. (or maybe we could invite different authors every year?)
Either or both would be great with me. But first, of course, I would like to do it one time. If it works, and I don't lose any money, and I don't see why it shouldn't be an every-so-often event.
1 quoted line
Btw, I did not mean to offend Josh by suggesting a con event.
You didn't!
2 quoted lines
I was
just trying to make logistics easier.
Please, if you want to do the same thing doing in Chicago sometime,
I think it would be great. If this is successful, I think that people will be doing it all over.
I would like to attend. I am located in Kentucky, and
I could see myself taking a bus as long as the ride
wasn't lets say over 40 hours? $200.00 seems more
than fair to me, and I would probably be willing to
pay more than that if necessary. But, if there is
anyone else that would want to go (12 person limit
right?) they could have my place. I'm extremely
interested in this, but I don't want to knock anyone
else out of getting to go that wants to. Especially
if they aren't that far away from where this would be
held at.
-BM
On Sun, 2003-07-27 at 11:43, Brandon Mason wrote:
I would like to attend. I am located in Kentucky, and
I could see myself taking a bus as long as the ride
wasn't lets say over 40 hours? $200.00 seems more
than fair to me, and I would probably be willing to
pay more than that if necessary. But, if there is
anyone else that would want to go (12 person limit
right?) they could have my place. I'm extremely
interested in this, but I don't want to knock anyone
else out of getting to go that wants to. Especially
if they aren't that far away from where this would be
held at.
I think, if it happens at all, it is going to be the first twelve people to put a deposit down. Either that or some kind of lottery.
As always, I welcome comments and input.
J.
___
I was going to say something about this and then forgot.
While I would very much like to be a part of something like this, and in fact live in the right part of the world - the east bay to be semi-precise -- in fact, my beloved Spousal Overunit went to hiskul in East San Jose - I do not believe it likely to happen.
My expectation is that, confronted with the suggestion of such a thing, Mr. Wolfe is likely to regard it as the concoction of a gaggle of hero-worshipping fanboys (and
-girls), and to conclude that his gradually decreasing store of time would be better spent working on the continuation of Latro's tale. Quite rightly, in my opinion.
Still, if I'm totally wrong about this and you convince him, count me in.
On Mon, 2003-07-28 at 08:52, Dan'l Danehy-Oakes wrote:
I was going to say something about this and then forgot.
While I would very much like to be a part of something like this, and in fact live in the right part of the world - the east bay to be semi-precise
-- in fact, my beloved Spousal Overunit went to hiskul in East San
Jose - I do not believe it likely to happen.
For your information, I live in a three bedroom house with a big yard and garden in a very nice, very middle class, very quiet neighborhood.
There are rough neighborhoods in East San Jose, some of them not too far away. Mine, however, is very quiet and peaceful.
I am sorry. There really is no polite way to say 'fuck you, white boy'.
I am ashamed.
1 quoted line
My expectation is that, confronted with the suggestion of such a thing, Mr. Wolfe is likely to regard it as the concoction of a gaggle of hero-worshippin fanboys (and -girls),
Thank you for your encouragement and support.
1 quoted line
Still, if I'm totally wrong about this and you convince him, count me in.
If this thing works at all, it will be done either on a first come, first served basis, or by a lottery.
In either case you will have the same chance as everybody else to participate.
.
You astonish me.
There is no polite way to say "fuck you, jew boy" either, but the fact that you are presumably jewish does not give you a free pass to deal out racial insults like this.
You owe the whole list an apology.
hartshorn
----- Original Message -----
5 quoted lines
From: "Josh Geller" brunians at brunians.org
I am sorry. There really is no polite way to say 'fuck you, white boy'.
I am ashamed.
On Mon, 2003-07-28 at 08:49, Andy Robertson wrote:
You astonish me.
Yeah, I astonish myself sometimes.
1 quoted line
There is no polite way to say "fuck you, jew boy" either, but the fact that you are presumably jewish does not give you a free pass to deal out racial insults like this.
What does being a Jew have to do with anything? I am, in fact, ethnically ashkenazi, but everyone who sees me considers me to be a white person, as I consider myself to be a white person.
Ashkenazi are all pretty white, and about half of us aren't even a little bit middle-eastern looking.
1 quoted line
You owe the whole list an apology.
I don't see that. I didn't insult the whole list. I insulted Dan, and I have apologized to Dan.
If you feel insulted by my insulting Dan, I suppose it doesn't cost me anything to apologize to you. I'm sorry, Andy.
.
Well we've had an unpleasantness on this list and once again I am extremely impressed by the enormous self-restraint and impeccable good manners of the vast majority of members of this list (myself excluded, of course).
5 quoted lines
At 11:08 AM -0700 7/28/03, Josh Geller wrote:
On Mon, 2003-07-28 at 08:49, Andy Robertson wrote:
> You owe the whole list an apology.
I don't see that. I didn't insult the whole list. I insulted Dan, and I have apologized to Dan.
In my opinion, Josh, posting the insult to the list rather than sending it as a private email is the equivalent of causing a scene in a public place and therefore you do owe the list as a whole an apology.
I agree with Dan'l that your Wolfe get-together is almost certainly not going to happen for the same reasons he gives. And you have, perhaps, made the odds of the success of the project an infinitesimal bit smaller by your demonstration of your highly developed ability to over-react to non-existent provocation. There was an extremely tiny but non-zero chance I might have decided to participate and pay a fee for at least a virtual membership in this event before your ill-considered remarks, but now the chance of my participation is zero.
I don't expect you be impressed by the above statement or care about my opinion at all. But if you now hesitate just a bit longer before you hit the send button after having written your next "hot-headed" reply then I will feel my message has served a useful purpose.
On Mon, 2003-07-28 at 21:58, William Ansley wrote:
At 11:08 AM -0700 7/28/03, Josh Geller wrote:
On Mon, 2003-07-28 at 08:49, Andy Robertson wrote:
Well we've had an unpleasantness on this list and once again I am extremely impressed by the enormous self-restraint and impeccable good manners of the vast majority of members of this list (myself excluded, of course).
You owe the whole list an apology.
I don't see that. I didn't insult the whole list. I insulted Dan, and I have apologized to Dan.
In my opinion, Josh, posting the insult to the list rather than sending it as a private email is the equivalent of causing a scene in a public place and therefore you do owe the list as a whole an apology.
Well! You are certainly entitled to your opinion. I disagree with it.
But it is obvious that you are offended, and I don't mind apologizing to you.
I'm sorry, William.
If you can give a better explanation as to how I insulted the list as a corporate whole, one that convinces me, I will be perfectly happy to issue a blanket apology. But really, I feel it is more meaningful if the people who feel insulted - like Andy and yourself - tell me about it in front of the list, and give me an opportunity to apologize to each one of you individually, also in front of the list.
Thank you very much for giving me this opportunity to apologize to you.
Josh
___
Urth Net