Index · 3 messages · 3 voices · 09 Oct – 12 Oct 1998

Digest urth.v019.n014

Download this conversation

Kieran Mullen09 Oct 1998, 19:15original as archived

↰ answers Robert Borski · by quotation

Robert Borski writes:

1 quoted line

I also think it's fairly obvious that Valeria is Catherine's mother (meaning Severian has slept with both grandmothers).

Umm... Obvious? Isn't there a problem with time here?

1 quoted line

Catherine also has access to the Corridors of Time.

Ah! So that's how you get around this one. Care to explain why you think the above are true? I had hoped that Wolfe was a great writer. From this mailing list he seems to be like one of those hack mystery writers who have the butler just coincidentally be the father of Lord Billings and be the brother-in-law of the deceased. Kieran Mullen

Peter Stephenson10 Oct 1998, 13:22original as archived

↳ follows Kieran Mullen · by subject

3 quoted lines

Kieran Mullen wrote: I had hoped that Wolfe was a great writer. From this mailing list he seems to be like one of those hack mystery writers who have the butler just coincidentally be the father of Lord Billings and be the brother-in-law of the deceased.

I have to pipe up and admit that I have worries along these line. The great strength I find in Wolfe is the overarching themes and links between them. Having all the characters tie up in this narrow way seems to reduce it to a certain extent to a family soap opera. Severian's family certainly should be important somehow, I'm just a bit worried about the way it's done. Wolfe's in good company, though; lots of major authors have links of this kind (Dickens is full of it, although I take it none of his characters are their own ancestors), but that doesn't make it `right'. But that's a highly personal assessment, of course. I'm entirely convinced the links are really there, and it's fascinating to hear all these things I never suspected. Indeed, you could quite easily read every word of the Book twice and not have the smallest idea what any of these arguments were about. (In fact, would somebody mind sketching a brief family history of Valeria for those of us left behind? ta.) corncrake (craking at the corn)

Peter Stephenson <pws at ibmth.df.unipi.it> Tel: +39 050 844536 WWW: http://www.ifh.de/~pws/ Dipartimento di Fisica, Via Buonarotti 2, 56100 Pisa, Italy

Michael Straight12 Oct 1998, 08:39original as archived

↳ follows Peter Stephenson · by subject

2 quoted lines

On Sat, 10 Oct 1998, Peter Stephenson wrote: I have to pipe up and admit that I have worries along these line. The great strength I find in Wolfe is the overarching themes and links between them. Having all the characters tie up in this narrow way seems to reduce it to a certain extent to a family soap opera. Severian's family certainly should be important somehow, I'm just a bit worried about the way it's done. Wolfe's in good company, though; lots of major authors have links of this kind (Dickens is full of it, although I take it none of his characters are their own ancestors), but that doesn't make it `right'.

I've long suspected I have some sort of deficiency because I am utterly unmoved by these kinds of revelations. Vader is Luke's father? Leia is Luke's sister? Yawn. Let's see some more spaceships blowing up. Dorcas's identity interests me more because it shows how she's been dead or suspended for a long time than because she's related to Severian. I guess the whole sleeping with your grandmother thing provokes a satisfying "eeeew!" as well. I just hope Silk doesn't turn out to be Severian's son, brother, clone, grandfather, or twin sister. Maybe my family life was just too humdrum for these kinds of things to have any emotional resonance for me. -Rostrum

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net