Urth Net

Index · 1 message · 01 Nov 1998

linguistics and sf

Download this conversation
Damien Broderick01 Nov 1998, 15:01originalas archived
linguistics and sf
< This post is interesting, because I recently saw a book by Jack Vance called The Languages of Pao, which said something like "The first science fiction book based on the science of linguistics" on the cover. I have no idea what the story is about. Since Wolfe says he was influenced by Vance, particularly the Dying Earth books, I wondered if there are any stories where someone has noticed any emphasis on linguistics. prion > Practically everything by Samuel R. Delany. Except that, alas, his notion of linguistics is still mired in Saussure and the whole erratic poststruck recension via Lacan. The NATIVE TONGUE/JUDAS ROSE books by Suzette Haden Elgin, a linguistics prof, in which Xian ayatollah-oppressed wimmin implausibly invent a language for themselves that more truly reflects their distinctive experience, and excludes the foe (a language, as it were, that men can't hear). Vance is full of (a crudely emphatic parody of) the Whorf posit, as are various other classic '50s Campbell-era stories and novels. Some guy with a Frog name who's a computational linguist and whose fairly recent book has GLASS in the title. At risk of a hernia, I lug out my Clute/Nicholls ENCYCLOPEDIA OF SF - yep, there's a long detailed entry by my old pal Peter Nicholls, who inter alia makes the disgraceful error of writing `deep structure' (the hidden cognitive substructure of variant sentences meaning the same thing) when he means `genetically-ordained grammar template' (the phenotypic universals instilled by a common genotype rather than by personal experience or cultural tradition - which can only set choices from those menus - required by regnant Chomskyan linguistics). Damien Broderick

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net