Urth Net

Index · 2 messages · 2 voices · 29 Jan 2000

Maximum Delusion theory--Ziggurat

Download this conversation
Patri1062929 Jan 2000, 21:08originalas archived
Maximum Delusion theory--Ziggurat
Must agree with Alga and Nutria. Swanwick's reading seems cockamamie to me. I mean where do we point at the text and say: There! He's a totally untrustworthy narrator? See? Where do we see some evidence of self-delusion, true psychosis? Where do we see him as murderous? All the violence in the story is directed at himself. And in self-defense at the end. Where do we see him threatening, wishing harm or ill on the coyote, his son, his children, his wife? Cloning? Where do we get cloning? Sure there's an analogy between the 3 woman and the women in his life. But cloning? The text does not suggest this to me after 4 readings. This reading, as far as I can tell, demands that we deny 90% of what we're told happened in the story. Wish I could expand, but must go. It's a dreadful interpretation of what I take to be a story of reconciliation between the sexes not madness or incest. But that's my take. Rave on lupines! Patrick O'leary
Jim Jordan29 Jan 2000, 15:47originalas archived
↳ follows Patri10629 · by subject
6 quoted lines
At 04:08 PM 1/29/00 EST, you wrote: Must agree with Alga and Nutria. Wish I could expand, but must go. It's a dreadful interpretation of what I take to be a story of reconciliation between the sexes not madness or incest. Patrick O'leary
Yeah. You other guys better watch it, or Patrick, Alga, and I are going to come over and beat you up. You know who you are, and so do we. Be afraid. Be very afraid. Nutria (slavering rat)

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net