Urth Net

Index · 3 messages · 3 voices · 16 Jan 2005

Gene 5e Wolfhead

Download this conversation
Jim Raylor16 Jan 2005, 10:01as archived
Gene 5e Wolfhead
I can't prove this. I have read t5hoc a few times but I started reading it with Google. A perilous venture. On first reading I thought it 3 stories set in a double planetary system and with a few characters and themes in common... I liked the first one best. I hadn't read much WOlfe then. But I felt I had missed something so I re-read it and was pleased that it revealed more, though I still felt there were deeper mysteries hidden. By the third reading I became convinced that this was not three stories but part of one continuous narrative. Now I am losing count... I got to page 9 and then I had to re-read what I had missed before and for a while I became stuck as though I had dropped anchor to find out why I was not moving. Levi's hypothesis The matter under discussion is an aleph. It is concealed in a name. This is ONE story told in three dissimilar ways. I cannot prove this, but I shall supply evidence so that you, dear reader, can make your own mind up on the case. The prosecution enters carrying a battered leather despatch box. =====
maru dubshinki16 Jan 2005, 10:11as archived
↳ in reply to Jim Raylor
That's an interesting idea. But my impression of cerberus was that it was three stories, three times, but one idea behind all. Somewhat like how Cerberus has three distinct heads, but each is all about cerberus and doggy-ness. Like math transformations, or the voices in a fugue. I look forward to Jim Raynor's per- prosecution. ~Maru Fugue listening to: Katamari Damacy's Fugue # 7777
36 quoted lines
Jim Raylor wrote: I can't prove this. I have read t5hoc a few times but I started reading it with Google. A perilous venture. On first reading I thought it 3 stories set in a double planetary system and with a few characters and themes in common... I liked the first one best. I hadn't read much WOlfe then. But I felt I had missed something so I re-read it and was pleased that it revealed more, though I still felt there were deeper mysteries hidden. By the third reading I became convinced that this was not three stories but part of one continuous narrative. Now I am losing count... I got to page 9 and then I had to re-read what I had missed before and for a while I became stuck as though I had dropped anchor to find out why I was not moving. Levi's hypothesis The matter under discussion is an aleph. It is concealed in a name. This is ONE story told in three dissimilar ways. I cannot prove this, but I shall supply evidence so that you, dear reader, can make your own mind up on the case. The prosecution enters carrying a battered leather despatch box. ===== ___________________________________________________________ ALL-NEW Yahoo! Messenger - all new features - even more fun! http://uk.messenger.yahoo.com _______________________________________________
Chris16 Jan 2005, 11:51as archived
↳ in reply to maru dubshinki
Personally I always thought of it musically, something like "Variations on a Theme by Proust".
40 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
That's an interesting idea. But my impression of cerberus was that it was three stories, three times, but one idea behind all. Somewhat like how Cerberus has three distinct heads, but each is all about cerberus and doggy-ness. Like math transformations, or the voices in a fugue. I look forward to Jim Raynor's per- prosecution. ~Maru Fugue listening to: Katamari Damacy's Fugue # 7777 Jim Raylor wrote:
I can't prove this. I have read t5hoc a few times but I started reading it with Google. A perilous venture. On first reading I thought it 3 stories set in a double planetary system and with a few characters and themes in common... I liked the first one best. I hadn't read much WOlfe then. But I felt I had missed something so I re-read it and was pleased that it revealed more, though I still felt there were deeper mysteries hidden. By the third reading I became convinced that this was not three stories but part of one continuous narrative. Now I am losing count... I got to page 9 and then I had to re-read what I had missed before and for a while I became stuck as though I had dropped anchor to find out why I was not moving. Levi's hypothesis The matter under discussion is an aleph. It is concealed in a name. This is ONE story told in three dissimilar ways. I cannot prove this, but I shall supply evidence so that you, dear reader, can make your own mind up on the case. The prosecution enters carrying a battered leather despatch box. ===== ___________________________________________________________ ALL-NEW Yahoo! Messenger - all new features - even more fun! http://uk.messenger.yahoo.com _______________________________________________

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net