Urth Net

Index · 2 messages · 2 voices · 30 Mar – 02 Apr 1998

Explication of a few sma

Download this conversation
Tony Ellis30 Mar 1998, 15:28originalas archived
Explication of a few sma
↰ answers Damien Broderick · by quotation
30/03/98 16:59 RE>Explication of a few small points
2 quoted lines
David Lebling wrote: The "teratoid sign" in TBOTNS is our radiation warning symbol.
I thought of this too... but decided no. Our radiation symbol is black on yellow, and this is crimson. Also, its simple rotational symmetry is hardly "teratoid". Finally, as far as we know, the mirrors have nothing to do with radiation. I'm sure that nice Father Inire wouldn't show little girls around the chamber if they did.
2 quoted lines
...Didn't someone report (somewhere in the archives) that Wolfe has said that no one was murdered by Alden Weer in Peace?
In the online People interview, Wolfe was asked if Weer killed many of the other characters in the book and responded "Let me think about that... no. I don't think so, no." Personally, I've never quite understood what the case against Weer was, re the librarian and the plant worker. Ok, fabrication is a strong theme in the novel, but Weer himself doesn't seem to go out of his way to lie to us (or rather, to himself). Or am I missing something? Damien, in your fascinating Peace essay a few posts back you say that
1 quoted line
The name of the narrator of Wolfe's The Fifth Head of Cerberus, never given in that text, can be determined to be Gene Wolfe.
I'm not quite sure how you arrive at this. Could you elaborate, please?
Michael Straight02 Apr 1998, 13:36originalas archived
↳ follows Tony Ellis · by subject
5 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
On 30 Mar 1998, Tony Ellis wrote: David Lebling wrote:
...Didn't someone report (somewhere in the archives) that Wolfe has said that no one was murdered by Alden Weer in Peace?
In the online People interview, Wolfe was asked if Weer killed many of the other characters in the book and responded "Let me think about that... no. I don't think so, no."
I'd always understood that quote to mean that, Weer did not kill "many" of the other characters of the book, not that he didn't kill anyone. I doubt Wolfe would have had to think about it if Weer was entirely innocent, and it seems pretty plain that he at least (accidentally) killed the boy at the top of the stairs. -Rostrum

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net