Urth Net

Index · 10 messages · 8 voices · 01 Nov – 14 Nov 2008

hirsute sev

Download this conversation
Marc Aramini01 Nov 2008, 17:19as archived
hirsute sev
The description of Sev is one of paleness punctuated by dark head hair - Thecla says he must stay out of the sun or his pale skin will burn terribly. This does not seem to jive in my mind with someone who has excessive body hair that would take away this paleness and cover him from the sun - and it is the veins on the back of his hands that make him a man, not his hairy chest. But I have no chest hair and it is certainly possible I am projecting a narcissistic image upon him that has no basis in the text.
Pedro Pereira01 Nov 2008, 17:24as archived
↳ in reply to Marc Aramini
If I rememeber correctly there's those hairy humans in the caves that Severian meets and scares with the light of The Claw who are supposedly humans who "regressed" to earlier evolutionary stages. I don't think there's any scientific basis for this at all, it's another example of Wolfe's Science Fantasy take on things. As for Severian, no, he's not hairy at all and there's no reason to believe humans in general are hairier in TBotNS, not only on a scientific basis, but also no textual evidence whatsoever.
Adam Thornton01 Nov 2008, 18:22as archived
↳ in reply to Marc Aramini
2 quoted lines
On Nov 1, 2008, at 12:19 PM, Marc Aramini wrote: But I have no chest hair and it is certainly possible I am projecting a narcissistic image upon him that has no basis in the text.
If it helps, I'm quite hairy, and I've always imagined Severian as a body-hairless metrosexual skinny white boy. Adam
James Wynn01 Nov 2008, 19:25as archived
↳ in reply to Pedro Pereira
4 quoted lines
Pedro says: If I rememeber correctly there's those hairy humans in the caves that Severian meets and scares with the light of The Claw who are supposedly humans who "regressed" to earlier evolutionary stages. I don't think there's any scientific basis for this at all, it's another example of Wolfe's Science Fantasy take on things.
IIRC, Severian believes that they are normal humans who have been artificially modified for the purpose the Autarch puts them to. He even posits that they might be aware that they have been misdeveloped in this fashion and resent it. Their Neanderthalishness might might havbe only a coincidental element of a utilitarian design. J.
Pedro Pereira01 Nov 2008, 19:27as archived
↳ in reply to James Wynn
thanks, didn't remember the case very well. Pedro From: crushtv at gmail.comTo: urth at lists.urth.netDate: Sat, 1 Nov 2008 14:25:01 -0500Subject: Re: (urth) hirsute sev
4 quoted lines
Pedro says: If I rememeber correctly there's those hairy humans in the caves that Severian meets and scares with the light of The Claw who are supposedly humans who "regressed" to earlier evolutionary stages. I don't think there's any scientific basis for this at all, it's another example of Wolfe's Science Fantasy take on things.
IIRC, Severian believes that they are normal humans who have been artificially modified for the purpose the Autarch puts them to. He even posits that they might be aware that they have been misdeveloped in this fashion and resent it. Their Neanderthalishness might might havbe only a coincidental element of a utilitarian design. J.
Son of Witz02 Nov 2008, 19:24as archived
↳ in reply to Marc Aramini
Ha. I almost had started a new thread with this title. but I wasn't sure I remembered the definition of hirsute properly. so when I googled it, it was all hairy porn links. yeah, Sev's a paie whiteboy by the text, as well as by the meta logic you've pointed out. I hate drawing body hair anyway. "skinny" though. he says he's muscular, so I figure he's at least very athletic looking. strapping young lad material. and Adam, thanks for your hairy perspective. ~witz
6 quoted lines
On Nov 1, 2008, at 10:19 AM, Marc Aramini wrote: The description of Sev is one of paleness punctuated by dark head hair - Thecla says he must stay out of the sun or his pale skin will burn terribly. This does not seem to jive in my mind with someone who has excessive body hair that would take away this paleness and cover him from the sun - and it is the veins on the back of his hands that make him a man, not his hairy chest. But I have no chest hair and it is certainly possible I am projecting a narcissistic image upon him that has no basis in the text. _______________________________________________
Craig Brewer13 Nov 2008, 20:58as archived
↳ in reply to Marc Aramini
Just a small point on Severian's coloring, but I was just looking back over Cyriaca's story in Sword, and, at one point, Severian mentions looking down at his "brown fingers." She also of course mentions the dark hairs on his hands, but the brown fingers seems interestingly different from Thecla's comment about his pale skin. So...pale with ruddy hands because his hands aren't covered by a mask/cloak, as is the rest of his body? Is "brown" here just a loose rendering of "vaguely beige" skin color? Or is this a contradiction? Or is Thecla's "pale" a relative pale rather than actually white or devoid of color? Why, in the end, would it matter, and what would Severian's skin color signify? An illustrator is of course naturally interested, but is Sev's skin color supposed to indicate something about his ethnicity, which would of course be filtered through years of Urth history. I'm simply trying to figure out if Sev's coloring is actually significant, or if I should stop worrying about it. I also thought I should mention that Thecla's worrying about a sunburn under a pale, dying sun seems odd. Yes, ultraviolet need not be accompanied by a "bright" light, but a deliberate mention of worrying about the harmful effects of a dim sun seems to stand out. ----- Original Message ---- From: Marc Aramini <marcaramini at yahoo.com> To: "urth at urth.net" <urth at urth.net> Sent: Saturday, November 1, 2008 12:19:21 PM Subject: (urth) hirsute sev The description of Sev is one of paleness punctuated by dark head hair - Thecla says he must stay out of the sun or his pale skin will burn terribly. This does not seem to jive in my mind with someone who has excessive body hair that would take away this paleness and cover him from the sun - and it is the veins on the back of his hands that make him a man, not his hairy chest. But I have no chest hair and it is certainly possible I am projecting a narcissistic image upon him that has no basis in the text.
John Watkins13 Nov 2008, 21:03as archived
↳ in reply to Craig Brewer
I just figured Severian was sun-browned from his travels by the time he meets Cyriaca, but pale from his time in the Citadel back in Shadow.
18 quoted lines
On 11/13/08, Craig Brewer <cnbrewer at yahoo.com> wrote: Just a small point on Severian's coloring, but I was just looking back over Cyriaca's story in Sword, and, at one point, Severian mentions looking down at his "brown fingers." She also of course mentions the dark hairs on his hands, but the brown fingers seems interestingly different from Thecla's comment about his pale skin. So...pale with ruddy hands because his hands aren't covered by a mask/cloak, as is the rest of his body? Is "brown" here just a loose rendering of "vaguely beige" skin color? Or is this a contradiction? Or is Thecla's "pale" a relative pale rather than actually white or devoid of color? Why, in the end, would it matter, and what would Severian's skin color signify? An illustrator is of course naturally interested, but is Sev's skin color supposed to indicate something about his ethnicity, which would of course be filtered through years of Urth history. I'm simply trying to figure out if Sev's coloring is actually significant, or if I should stop worrying about it. I also thought I should mention that Thecla's worrying about a sunburn under a pale, dying sun seems odd. Yes, ultraviolet need not be accompanied by a "bright" light, but a deliberate mention of worrying about the harmful effects of a dim sun seems to stand out. ----- Original Message ---- From: Marc Aramini <marcaramini at yahoo.com> To: "urth at urth.net" <urth at urth.net> Sent: Saturday, November 1, 2008 12:19:21 PM Subject: (urth) hirsute sev The description of Sev is one of paleness punctuated by dark head hair - Thecla says he must stay out of the sun or his pale skin will burn terribly. This does not seem to jive in my mind with someone who has excessive body hair that would take away this paleness and cover him from the sun - and it is the veins on the back of his hands that make him a man, not his hairy chest. But I have no chest hair and it is certainly possible I am projecting a narcissistic image upon him that has no basis in the text. _______________________________________________
Craig Brewer13 Nov 2008, 21:17as archived
↳ in reply to John Watkins
It's always nice to be reminded of your razor, Mr. Occam. ----- Original Message ---- From: John Watkins <john.watkins04 at gmail.com> To: The Urth Mailing List <urth at lists.urth.net> Sent: Thursday, November 13, 2008 3:03:50 PM Subject: Re: (urth) hirsute sev I just figured Severian was sun-browned from his travels by the time he meets Cyriaca, but pale from his time in the Citadel back in Shadow.
Jeff Wilson14 Nov 2008, 08:15as archived
↳ in reply to Craig Brewer
2 quoted lines
Craig Brewer wrote: I also thought I should mention that Thecla's worrying about a sunburn under a pale, dying sun seems odd. Yes, ultraviolet need not be accompanied by a "bright" light, but a deliberate mention of worrying about the harmful effects of a dim sun seems to stand out.
ozone levels could be low after chiliads of neglect and seepage from old refrigeration units or Erebusforming.
Jeff Wilson - jwilson at io.com < http://www.io.com/~jwilson >

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net