Urth Net
Baldander's dream
4 quoted lines
Gerry Quinn: Football is as pertinent to the Cumaean as virgin acolytes
and a desire to rule. That is to say, the personality characterics of
the Cumaean as written resemble those of Echidna about as much as they
resemble those of Lionel Messi.
Sorry, I am not familiar with "Lionel Messi". But I disagree that he and football have a relationship to these BotNS characters.
Mythological Typhon is a multi-headed monster representing storm winds. His wife is Echidna, a cave-dwelling snakey sort of female. Together they are "The Mother and Father Of All Monsters". Their Whorl children are all named for mythological monsters.
Typhon is found on Urth. Scylla, in one form or another, is found on Urth. I see no reason against Echidna also also being found on Urth. Are there any cave-dwelling snakey females on Urth who are associated with human sacrifice? Yep.
As previously mentioned, the mythological link between the Cumaean Sibyl and Echidna is the Pythian Oracle. It is Apollo who ties these two oracles together, not to mention the cave and snake.
1 quoted line
Nor do I recall Typhon asking after his wife when Severian subsequently encountered him.
I don't understand why he would. Moreover, Typhon on Urth and in the Whorl
does not seem particularly devoted to his wife, nor vice versa.
1 quoted line
Should not these chains of allusion, if they are intended to be meaningful, dip at some point into the personaities or storyline encountered in the text?
I find snakes and caves and human sacrifice to be sufficient. This isn't a
story about the gods/aliens who lurk behind the scenes. These are stories
about Severian and Silk and Horn.
1 quoted line
It's true that in the promiscuously retconned mythologies of Ancient Greece and elsewhere, characters absorbed characteristics from each other such that probably no two characters in myth can be seen as entirely separate. That seems reason enough in itself to take the position that a relatively vague link has no significance in terms of identifying characters associated with the particular mythological characters.
I disagree. As Severian serves as a Christ-like figure, so the somewhat indistinctly defined gods/aliens of Urth/Whorl/Blue serve as the Sun Series versions of our earthly pagan gods who blurred and merged with each other eventually evolving into Christianity.