Urth Net

Index · 2 messages · 2 voices · 26 Oct 1999

children?

Download this conversation
shannon wilde26 Oct 1999, 16:13originalas archived
children?
44 quoted lines
--- shannon wilde <swilde_99 at yahoo.com> wrote: Date: Tue, 26 Oct 1999 16:07:26 -0700 (PDT) From: shannon wilde <swilde_99 at yahoo.com> Subject: Re: children? To: urth at best.lists.com Forgive me, all, I couldn't resist replying to the "survival as kiddy lit" bit. I myself was turned onto Fahrenheit 451, first the book, then the movie, when I was approx 5-6 yrs old. By third grade, I had read all of The Lord of the Rings and had read both Dune and The Dispossessed by age 11. Of course that goes for The Metamorphosis and some of Borges, too. Not bragging, really. My point is that good,and great, literature is both timeless and ageless for those with the mind's eye to see. Heck, I read Grimm's and Calvino's collected fairytales, and Rudyard Kipling, with even more pleasure than I did as a child. Admittedly, Proust et al might be a bit much for most youngsters (and adults) but if TBOTNS had been published when I waas shorter, it would surely have been "gold" to me, even as The Dying Earth and so much of Vance was. You all were probably pretty exceptional folk throughout your lives, so you know what I mean. Like Bryan Cholfin (formerly editor of Crank! mag) Wolfe was formative to my critical and aesthetic appreciation of modern literature. I wonder how those solitary tots of today will be entranced by the many wonders of Urth and sky...presumably w/o the tall, grey-robed figures abducting them. ===== __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Bid and sell for free at http://auctions.yahoo.com
=====
Daniel Fusch26 Oct 1999, 23:32originalas archived
↳ follows shannon wilde · by subject
Shannon, (snip) My point is that good,and
2 quoted lines
great, literature is both timeless and ageless for those with the mind's eye to see.
Good point! I also discovered many of my favorite books at an early age...Lord of the Rings at age 8, A Wrinkle in Time at age 7 or 8, Kipling shortly afterward, and so on. Great literature IS ageless/timeless! Maybe, then, we should hope that all the great novels--past and present--survive into the future as children's lit! Daniel

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net