Here is one more thing that bugs me: has the Short Sun narrator been gone TWO YEARS or THREE YEARS? you can't get the same number in the text. Conjunction has happened. More time dilation? How long has Horn been gone?
Someone (Blattid, right?) posted a huge list of objections. I mostly agree with Andy's defenses. I NEVER posited a space warp that the whorl flew into - i thought it flew in a circle. As far as I know, you can control direction in a space ship or you are doomed to an eternity of going forward.
Polyploidy is instant speciation - that's the whole point. It can spring up in one generation, and disappear in one generation. No time needs to pass to create new species.
I NEVER said that Blue was Urth of the past - it is Ushas of a somewhat distant future - enough time for the trees to kill the colonists on Lune, come to Urth, kill everyone there and die out or "move on" in one (or a few) generation(s) before the whorl comes back to recolonize the planet. So many things are the same (flooded planet, wall underwater, analog species) And I'm sorry, hybridization is SOOO textually prevalent, as is man to flower imagery. I HAVE posited a prototype green man - who isn't green yet. He can't feed in the winter, he doesn't eat, and he has normal limbs. Who is he? Your humble narrator Silk. and he has wounds from branches - he runs into a tree as soon as Hyacinth dies.
As I've said before, the moon (green) is in an oscillating, self correcting orbit around blue - it can always be seen in the sky. It was pulled from its decayed orbit by the new sun. Green orbits Blue in oscillation, sometimes close, sometimes far, but that has nothing to do with its orbital period.
also, there is every indication that the children of polyploid species are not the same. Look at the corn - the second generation is weaker and even a different color. Indeed, a return to the haploid state is necessary for children to be viable - and this is what we have in the life cycle of the inhumu, clearly delineated in the text. If the Neighbors go a generation or two, perhaps they will lose those excess limbs. (If they can regain fertility at all, because hybrids are notoriously infertile). Also, the inhumu do not gain excess limbs because they do not instantly create a new species: they are simple sexual producers who feast on blood, save it, and then incorporate that DNA into their children. That is different than the trees instant consumption and recombination. They are different species working on the same terraformed principles.
And Gene wolfe sets up the mystery of the vanished people as something that can be solved: Silk/Horn claims that his son already knows where the vanished people went and where they came from, but that it would be better if "he figured it out for himself", which implies that a reader of the text should be able to figure it out, too.
Marc
2 quoted lines · depth 2
Marc wrote:
Here is one more thing that bugs me: has the Short Sun narrator been gone
TWO YEARS or THREE YEARS? you can't get the same number in the text. Conjunction has happened. More time dilation? How long has Horn been gone?<<
As I said before, three years, at the time of Blanko's war. (IGJ, 294)
2 quoted lines · depth 2
As I've said before, the moon (green) is in an oscillating, self
correcting orbit around blue - it can always be seen in the sky. It was pulled from its decayed orbit by the new sun. Green orbits Blue in oscillation, sometimes close, sometimes far, but that has nothing to do with its orbital period.<<
No, Green is not always visible in Blue's sky.
"Night had come already to the eastern sky, scattering the short suns of other whorls across its black velvet. Soon Green would rise, almost a second sun, yet baleful as a curse . . ." (Exodus, 383)
-Roy
1 quoted line
Someone (Blattid, right?) posted a huge list of objections. I mostly agree with Andy's defenses.
Yes, that was me. And some of the defenses were good, but miss the point -- which, however, Andy himself does get: that (in his own words) "there is no compelling reason to believe" the Blue=Urth theory.
You have a very pretty theory, which however requires a great deal of defending -- that is, your hypothesis requires a significant number of related hypotheses to make it feasible. For such a jerryrigged theory to be acceptable, it requires some kind of "smoking gun" textual evidence -- some place where the author is unambiguously (or, well, as unambiguous as anything ever gets in Wolfe) pointing us at it. And while the whole hybridization thing is clearly tremendously important, it isn't a smoking gun for this.
Consider, though, that most of your theory works perfectly well
without adding the "Blue = Urth" hypothesis. I still am less than convinced that the Narrator is a tree that becomes a Neighbor, takes over Horn's life, and gets transmigrated into Silk's body, but by itself it's worthy of consideration; it's only piling "Blue = Urth" on top of it that it becomes top-heavy and collapses.
1 quoted line
I NEVER posited a space warp that the whorl flew into
My apologies. I thought someone did -- I was pretty sure this
was your explanation of how the Old Sun could be visible as a
star from the Grue system.
1 quoted line
Polyploidy is instant speciation - that's the whole point.
Only if it is transmissible. Highly questionable. And even more questionable that it would arise uniformly among humans, crocodilians, and elephants, in a way that completely pushes the "old" species out of existence.
1 quoted line
I NEVER said that Blue was Urth of the past
No, someone else (I don't recall who) suggested that.
1 quoted line
hybridization is SOOO textually prevalent, as is man to flower imagery.
Absolutely; this stuff is important.
1 quoted line
I HAVE posited a prototype green man - who isn't green yet. He can't feed in the winter, he doesn't eat, and he has normal limbs. Who is he? Your humble narrator Silk.
H'mmmm... I think that, like Blue=Urth, this is unnecessary for your more general hypothesis (and indeed, if Blue =/= Urth, the whole question of the "green man future" is irrelevant. No doubt, an eight-legged irrelevant.)
2 quoted lines
and he has wounds from branches - he runs into a tree as soon
as Hyacinth dies.
Completely conjectural, of course, and unneeded ...
2 quoted lines
As I've said before, the moon (green) is in an oscillating,
self correcting orbit around blue
What on Earth (or in space) is a "self correcting orbit?"
1 quoted line
Also, the inhumu do not gain excess limbs because they do not instantly create a new species: they are simple sexual producers who feast on blood, save it, and then incorporate that DNA into their children. That is different than the trees instant consumption and recombination.
Just a fussy point. One male inhumu; one female inhuma; many inhumi, male or female or both.
And weren't you saying earlier that the inhumi were the trees? Or, no, that was the Neighbors. I'm so confused!
2 quoted lines
They are different species working on the same terraformed
principles.
I guess the biggest question here would be "why in Hell would anyone 'terraform' (I assume you mean "genetically engineered principles") species to do this? "H'mmm. Alzabos, notules, salamanders ... naaah, there aren't enough monsters in the universe to really threaten our species' survival. Hey, I know! I'll create a bunch of monsters that incorporate the DNA of their victims and absorb memory! And the trees can go all polyploid to have extra limbs!" H'mmmm. No, I really have a lot of trouble imagining anyone's motives for this...
6 quoted lines
And Gene wolfe sets up the mystery of the vanished people as
something that can be solved: Silk/Horn claims that his son
already knows where the vanished people went and where they
came from, but that it would be better if "he figured it out
for himself", which implies that a reader of the text should
be able to figure it out, too.
Quite likely. That doesn't mean that this is the answer.
--Dan'l
Urth Net