Urth Net

Index · 6 messages · 4 voices · 08 Aug – 09 Aug 2006

new history of the Peloponnesian War

Download this conversation
Russell Wodell08 Aug 2006, 15:18as archived
new history of the Peloponnesian War
This might be helpful for those (like me) still struggling to understand the historical background of the Latro series. http://www.claremont.org/writings/crb/summer2006/kopff.html
Matthew King08 Aug 2006, 16:07as archived
↳ in reply to Russell Wodell
The author of this review (Victor Davis Hanson) wrote a chapter about the naval battle of Salamis in his book Carnage and Culture. Salamis is the name "translated" by Latro as meaning Peace. I had read Carnage and Culture shortly before I discovered Wolfe, and I was thrilled when I recognized what Latro was writing about. Another great resource for historical background is the Teaching Company's audio lectures on Herodotos.
6 quoted lines
On Aug 8, 2006, at 10:18 AM, Russell Wodell wrote: This might be helpful for those (like me) still struggling to understand the historical background of the Latro series. http://www.claremont.org/writings/crb/summer2006/kopff.html _______________________________________________
Matthew King08 Aug 2006, 16:10as archived
↳ in reply to Matthew King
I misread that web page. Hanson is the author of the book in question, which means I'm about to go buy it right now. The Peloponnesian war, I should note, takes place well after the events in the Soldier books, and involves the Spartans and their allies against the Athenians and their allies.
2 quoted lines
On Aug 8, 2006, at 11:07 AM, Matthew King wrote: The author of this review (Victor Davis Hanson) wrote a chapter...
Chris08 Aug 2006, 19:27as archived
↳ in reply to Matthew King
I am not familiar with the work, but I would be slightly wary of reading too much into Latro's story from a modern book about its historical background. This background is, for Wolfe, seen more through the eyes of Herodotus, Thucydides or Xenophon.
12 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
The author of this review (Victor Davis Hanson) wrote a chapter about the naval battle of Salamis in his book Carnage and Culture. Salamis is the name "translated" by Latro as meaning Peace. I had read Carnage and Culture shortly before I discovered Wolfe, and I was thrilled when I recognized what Latro was writing about. Another great resource for historical background is the Teaching Company's audio lectures on Herodotos. On Aug 8, 2006, at 10:18 AM, Russell Wodell wrote:
This might be helpful for those (like me) still struggling to understand the historical background of the Latro series. http://www.claremont.org/writings/crb/summer2006/kopff.html _______________________________________________
Matthew King08 Aug 2006, 21:36as archived
↳ in reply to Chris
2 quoted lines
On Aug 8, 2006, at 2:27 PM, Chris wrote: I am not familiar with the work, but I would be slightly wary of reading too much into Latro's story from a modern book about its historical background. This background is, for Wolfe, seen more through the eyes of Herodotus, Thucydides or Xenophon.
The focus of Carnage and Culture is on the nature and development of Western military prowess, so the chapter on Salamis is not directly relevant to Soldier of the Mist. As I recall it, Latro doesn't tell us much about the battle of Peace. Knowing a little about the battle, the strategy of Themistocles, and the appalling human loss on the side of the Persians: I say knowing some of this makes for a richer reading of Mist. Regarding wariness toward modern books: where do you suppose the authors get their historical information about the Persian war if not from Herodotos, et al.
Mo Holkar / UKG09 Aug 2006, 13:55as archived
↳ follows Matthew King · by subject
3 quoted lines
At 22:36 08/08/2006, Matthew wrote: Regarding wariness toward modern books: where do you suppose the authors get their historical information about the Persian war if not from Herodotos, et al.
I think the point was though that Wolfe relishes and draws on the oddities and fantasies of Herodotus, which may be dismissed as unhistorical by modern scholars. So Herodotus may be in some ways more "infomative" when reading Wolfe than a 'but this is what actually happened' account. Mo

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net