Urth Net

Index · 1 message · 24 Nov 2011

Auk/Hyacinth/Chenille/Tartaros

Download this conversation
Andrew Mason24 Nov 2011, 14:16as archived
Auk/Hyacinth/Chenille/Tartaros
↰ answers James Wynn · by quotation
3 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
James Wynn wrote: Why do you say he kidnapped her for sacrifice?
Well, he did kidnap her. The very requirement to kidnap someone assumes that no one could be procured to go willingly.
Sorry, I wasn't clear enough. Of course he kidnapped her. The question is why think it was for sacrifice that he did so. I don't think Tartaros wanted him to kidnap anyone; the woman he had in mind, Chenille, was there willingly. But Auk, who is in a confused state, hearing 'A woman is vital,' and finding that Chenille has gone, grabs the only woman to hand, Hyacinth, who, unsurprisingly, is unwilling. As to the real reason - I think Tartaros, who is going to send Auk to start a new colony, wants him to bring a potential partner with whom he can have children. Later, when recruiting people for the expedition, Auk says every man must bring a woman and every woman a man. . So, if she was vital...
1 quoted line
If Tartaros needed any woman (as his statement implied) why not Hy?
He says 'Go to the woman.. A woman is vital.' So, he has a particular woman in mind, but she matters because she is a a woman (not because she is a prostitute, or Silk's sister, or....) My explanation makes sense of this, I think.

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net