Urth Net

Index · 6 messages · 5 voices · 29 Dec – 30 Dec 2013

This Week in Google Alerts: more _Land Across_

Download this conversation
Gwern Branwen29 Dec 2013, 16:48as archived
This Week in Google Alerts: more _Land Across_
1 quoted line
Whether you subscribe to the theory that Wolfe is some kind of hothouse-cultivated Ent, or “merely” a human genius, you’ll want to read his new novel The Land Across. The author graciously took the time to speak with me via email about the genesis of his typically inventive new work, the state of 21st-century SF, and many other subjects. An edited transcript of our conversation follows, below. — Paul Di Filippo
Daniel Otto Jack Petersen29 Dec 2013, 17:53as archived
↳ in reply to Gwern Branwen
*http://jdbookreview.com/gene-wolfe-no-comparison/ <http://jdbookreview.com/gene-wolfe-no-comparison/> interview:> Whether you subscribe to the theory that Wolfe is some kind of hothouse-cultivated Ent, or “merely” a human genius, you’ll want to read his new novel The Land Across. The author graciously took the time to speak with me via email about the genesis of his typically inventive new work, the state of 21st-century SF, and many other subjects. An edited transcript of our conversation follows, below. — Paul Di Filippo* For any other out-of-it sap like me, who didn't know what 'the Singularity' was that Di Filippo asked Wolfe about, here's a very helpful article I found (summary: it's 'the Rapture for nerds'): http://io9.com/5534848/what-is-the-singularity-and-will-you-live-to-see-it Knowing what it is makes Wolfe's answer all the more fascinating and tantalising... -DOJP
14 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
Whether you subscribe to the theory that Wolfe is some kind of hothouse-cultivated Ent, or “merely” a human genius, you’ll want to read his new novel The Land Across. The author graciously took the time to speak with me via email about the genesis of his typically inventive new work, the state of 21st-century SF, and many other subjects. An edited transcript of our conversation follows, below. — Paul Di Filippo
-- gwern http://www.gwern.net _______________________________________________
Gerry Quinn29 Dec 2013, 18:08as archived
↳ in reply to Gwern Branwen
From: Gwern Branwen http://jdbookreview.com/gene-wolfe-no-comparison/ interview: 'Gene Wolfe easily admits to being a supernatural being. How else to explain his famous comment that editor Damon Knight, whose ORBIT series of anthologies helped launch Wolfe’s career, “grew me from a bean?”?' Hmm, if we are to assume it was a black bean, it would not make him the nicest kind of supernatural being! [I'm assuming that the story of the black beans cast into the sea in BotNS is meant to refer to the origin of Abaia, Erebus and the rest.] - Gerry Quinn
Antonin Scriabin29 Dec 2013, 20:48as archived
↳ in reply to Gerry Quinn
The Singularity is a pretty popular trope in modern, mainstream sci-fi. Charles Stross' "Accelerando" and Harrison's "Light" come to mind. I didn't particularly care for either one, I think it makes for lazy writing. Tech becomes magic, but characters aren't mystified, they are experts. It is easy to explain away problems in the narrative.
12 quoted lines
On Dec 29, 2013 1:09 PM, "Gerry Quinn" <gerry at bindweed.com> wrote: From: Gwern Branwen http://jdbookreview.com/gene-wolfe-no-comparison/ interview: 'Gene Wolfe easily admits to being a supernatural being. How else to explain his famous comment that editor Damon Knight, whose ORBIT series of anthologies helped launch Wolfe’s career, “grew me from a bean?”?' Hmm, if we are to assume it was a black bean, it would not make him the nicest kind of supernatural being! [I'm assuming that the story of the black beans cast into the sea in BotNS is meant to refer to the origin of Abaia, Erebus and the rest.] - Gerry Quinn _______________________________________________
Lee30 Dec 2013, 19:22as archived
↳ follows Antonin Scriabin · by subject
1 quoted line
Gerry Quinn: Hmm, if we are to assume it was a black bean, it would not make him the nicest kind of supernatural being! [I'm assuming that the story of the black beans cast into the sea in BotNS is meant to refer to the origin of Abaia, Erebus and the rest.]
With recognition of the lightheartedness of this reply, I truly do not think that Gene Wolfe considers himself to be the "nicest" of people. I haven't met him in person but I know he is often described as "genial". Still in the tone of some of his answers to direct questions, I know he has a sharp side. But these are all external judgements anyway. I find Wolfe's self-assessments best exemplified in his most autobiographical characters (Weer, Severian and Horn, imho). In these characters I find self-criticism which goes beyond acknowledgement of imperfection and which drifts toward true confession and self- condemnation. Moreover, if the role of author may be considered as demiurgical creator, as has been discussed in other threads, perhaps the comparison of Wolfe himself to giant god-like monsters is apt. If "black beans" hold the origin of "Abaia, Erebus and the rest", then Scylla must be included and thus, by extension, Typhon/Pas and Echidna (whom I find difficult to disconnect from The Cumaean).
Gerry Quinn30 Dec 2013, 22:48as archived
↳ in reply to Lee
From: Lee
1 quoted line
I haven't met him in person but I know he is often described as "genial". Still in thetone of some of his answers to direct questions, I know he has a sharp side. But these are all external judgements anyway.
Yes, he comes across as genial but often suddenly prickly at times. <Shrug> I love the books, I'm not actually all that concerned about the author.
3 quoted lines
Moreover, if the role of author may be considered as demiurgical creator, as has been discussed in other threads, perhaps the comparison of Wolfe himself to giant god-likemonsters is apt. If "black beans" hold the origin of "Abaia, Erebus and the rest", then Scylla must be included and thus, by extension, Typhon/Pas and Echidna (whom I find difficult to disconnect from The Cumaean).
I don't believe Typhon had the same origin as the sea monsters. Typhon is relatively human, I think. I doubt Wolfe would approve, but I do actually imagine the sea monsters in terms of 'singularity' concepts - they are creatures that can reconstruct themselves on a molecular level, and they have brains or other devices capable of powerful computations. They are gods [or demons] by our standards. I think the 'seeds; were nanofactories that built them. But that is equally true of all the seeds of living organisms. - Gerry Quinn

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net