Urth Net

Index · 7 messages · 7 voices · 07 Apr – 10 Apr 2006

Juturna

Download this conversation
Roy C. Lackey07 Apr 2006, 18:35as archived
Juturna
↰ answers Roy C. Lackey · by quotation
2 quoted lines
Just to muddy the waters a little more . . . earlier I wrote: Back in the throne room, Sev had asked her if she remembered saving him when he was a boy: "No. It hasn't yet occurred. It will, because you spoke." (306) Very curious. Sev's pronouncement thus became a prophesy. The New Sun and the flood were established facts as she spoke before the throne, she knew for a fact that Sev would succeed in bringing the New Sun, yet she came there to save him anyway that day if she could and she would see to it that she saved him from drowning in her future, which was his past. It seems to me that she succeeded on both counts.
The meeting in the throne room with Juturna was the third for Sev. The second meeting was at the Cephissus river, when she tried to seduce him. At that time she mentioned having previously saved him from drowning among the clotted weeds in the Gyoll. Ergo, since from her perspective there in the throne room she had yet to save him from drowning in the Gyoll, for her the meeting at the Cephissus cannot have happened yet, either. Yet she seems to know Sev. If that meeting in the throne room was not her first, when could she have known him earlier, if not from their coming encounter (coming from Sev's point of view) after the flood? -Roy
nastler09 Apr 2006, 09:53as archived
↳ in reply to Roy C. Lackey
Juturna (and nenuphars)
Roy, I don't think I have understand the problem with this.
1 quoted line
From Juturnas POV she meets Sev in the throne room and
he makes his "prophesy" that she will save him from drowning in Gyoll. She searchs "backwards" through his life and meets Sev at the sand bank where (among other things) she mentions that it was (will be) her that saves him from the weeds. When she reaches the moment where the nenuphars attempt to drown the NS she saves him. Why are these plants the image of "the death of the sun" anyway? "glossy, pale leaves and azure flower." "black roots as fine and strong as hair, reaching down into the dark waters". What forces are represented by these plants? Why do they wish to drown the sun? Would they not thrive in a sunnier Ushas? Are they non-terrestrial? I think they must be. They are "weeds" after all. They have roots reaching into dark waters, but are opposed by the Undines. Who can clear this up? nastler --- "Roy C. Lackey" <rclackey at stic.net> skrev:
42 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
Just to muddy the waters a little more . . . earlier I wrote:
Back in the throne room, Sev had asked her if she remembered saving him when he was a boy: "No. It hasn't yet occurred. It will, because you spoke." (306) Very curious. Sev's pronouncement thus became a prophesy. The New Sun and the flood were established facts as she spoke before the throne, she knew for a fact that Sev would succeed in bringing the New Sun, yet she came there to save him anyway that day if she could and she would see to it that she saved him from drowning in her future, which was his past. It seems to me that she succeeded on both counts.
The meeting in the throne room with Juturna was the third for Sev. The second meeting was at the Cephissus river, when she tried to seduce him. At that time she mentioned having previously saved him from drowning among the clotted weeds in the Gyoll. Ergo, since from her perspective there in the throne room she had yet to save him from drowning in the Gyoll, for her the meeting at the Cephissus cannot have happened yet, either. Yet she seems to know Sev. If that meeting in the throne room was not her first, when could she have known him earlier, if not from their coming encounter (coming from Sev's point of view) after the flood? -Roy _______________________________________________
Tristan Davenport09 Apr 2006, 18:02as archived
↳ in reply to nastler
Juturna (and nenuphars)
2 quoted lines
Why are these plants the image of "the death of the sun" anyway? "glossy, pale leaves and azure flower."
There are references throughout the NS books to the paleness of the plants; presumably the dying sun is not bright enough to stimulate chlorophyll production. This is contrasted with the rich green of plants under a healthy sun. So by the very fact of their glossy paleness, the nenuphars reflect the dying of the sun. Then I suppose there's the metaphorical meaning of their role in Sev's near-drowning. (Question: Why are the plants on Urth pale, while those on the moon apparently quite green?) Tristan tristan_davenport at hotmail.com
73 quoted lines · 1–3 deep
From: nastler <nastler at yahoo.dk> Reply-To: The Urth Mailing List <urth at lists.urth.net> To: The Urth Mailing List <urth at lists.urth.net> Subject: Re: (urth) Juturna (and nenuphars) Date: Sun, 9 Apr 2006 11:53:49 +0200 (CEST) Roy, I don't think I have understand the problem with this.
From Juturnas POV she meets Sev in the throne room and he makes his "prophesy" that she will save him from drowning in Gyoll. She searchs "backwards" through his life and meets Sev at the sand bank where (among other things) she mentions that it was (will be) her that saves him from the weeds. When she reaches the moment where the nenuphars attempt to drown the NS she saves him.
Why are these plants the image of "the death of the sun" anyway? "glossy, pale leaves and azure flower." "black roots as fine and strong as hair, reaching down into the dark waters". What forces are represented by these plants? Why do they wish to drown the sun? Would they not thrive in a sunnier Ushas? Are they non-terrestrial? I think they must be. They are "weeds" after all. They have roots reaching into dark waters, but are opposed by the Undines. Who can clear this up? nastler --- "Roy C. Lackey" <rclackey at stic.net> skrev:
Just to muddy the waters a little more . . . earlier I wrote:
Back in the throne room, Sev had asked her if she remembered saving him when he was a boy: "No. It hasn't yet occurred. It will, because you spoke." (306) Very curious. Sev's pronouncement thus became a prophesy. The New Sun and the flood were established facts as she spoke before the throne, she knew for a fact that Sev would succeed in bringing the New Sun, yet she came there to save him anyway that day if she could and she would see to it that she saved him from drowning in her future, which was his past. It seems to me that she succeeded on both counts.
The meeting in the throne room with Juturna was the third for Sev. The second meeting was at the Cephissus river, when she tried to seduce him. At that time she mentioned having previously saved him from drowning among the clotted weeds in the Gyoll. Ergo, since from her perspective there in the throne room she had yet to save him from drowning in the Gyoll, for her the meeting at the Cephissus cannot have happened yet, either. Yet she seems to know Sev. If that meeting in the throne room was not her first, when could she have known him earlier, if not from their coming encounter (coming from Sev's point of view) after the flood? -Roy _______________________________________________
Dan'l Danehy-Oakes09 Apr 2006, 19:29as archived
↳ in reply to Tristan Davenport
Juturna (and nenuphars)
1 quoted line
On 4/9/06, Tristan Davenport <tristan_davenport at hotmail.com> wrote: (Question: Why are the plants on Urth pale, while those on the moon apparently quite green?)
Purely speculation but -- Lune has a less dense atmosphere, so the surface receives more insolation. --Dan'l
I do not fear Satan half so much as I fear those who fear him. -- St Teresa of Avila http://www.livejournal.com/users/sturgeonslawyer
don doggett09 Apr 2006, 21:17as archived
↳ in reply to Dan'l Danehy-Oakes
Juturna (and nenuphars)
Perhaps, but Wolfe has also shown time and again that he his willing to forsake literal truth and internal consistency to make room for the right poetic imagery. The laws of dream and story far outweigh the laws of physics in his work, imho. Quite in keeping with the Catholic undertones of his major works, I think. Don
1 quoted line
Dan'l Danehy-Oakes <danldo at gmail.com> wrote: On 4/9/06, Tristan Davenport wrote: (Question: Why are the plants on Urth pale, while those on the moon apparently quite green?)
Purely speculation but -- Lune has a less dense atmosphere, so the surface receives more insolation. --Dan'l
I do not fear Satan half so much as I fear those who fear him. -- St Teresa of Avila http://www.livejournal.com/users/sturgeonslawyer
Jeff Wilson10 Apr 2006, 01:50as archived
↳ in reply to Dan'l Danehy-Oakes
Juturna (and nenuphars)
5 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
Dan'l Danehy-Oakes wrote: On 4/9/06, Tristan Davenport <tristan_davenport at hotmail.com> wrote:
(Question: Why are the plants on Urth pale, while those on the moon apparently quite green?)
Purely speculation but -- Lune has a less dense atmosphere, so the surface receives more insolation.
Perhaps, but there's no guarantee that there are any plants still on Lune at the time of the narrative. Conflation and multiplication of identities over ages is a very strong theme here as in other Wolfe. The green color could be something else entirely, and presumed to be the forrests of old, if it ever was. Algae farms meant to feed the many billions of Earth could retain their green color from superficial, topical growth even after millenia of neglect. Or some ancient ruler could have proclaimed the moon be pained green in his honor. The real answer is of course that the author really likes to write about blue planets with bright green companions, as he does in 5HC and SS.
Jeff Wilson - jwilson at io.com < http://www.io.com/~jwilson >
David Duffy10 Apr 2006, 04:42as archived
↳ in reply to Jeff Wilson
Juturna (and nenuphars)
11 quoted lines · 1–3 deep
On Sun, 9 Apr 2006, Jeff Wilson wrote: Dan'l Danehy-Oakes wrote:
On 4/9/06, Tristan Davenport <tristan_davenport at hotmail.com> wrote:
(Question: Why are the plants on Urth pale, while those on the moon apparently quite green?)
Purely speculation but -- Lune has a less dense atmosphere, so the surface receives more insolation.
Perhaps, but there's no guarantee that there are any plants still on Lune at the time of the narrative. Conflation and multiplication of identities over ages is a very strong theme here as in other Wolfe. The green color could be something else entirely, [SNIP] The real answer is of course that the author really likes to write about blue planets with bright green companions, as he does in 5HC and SS.
It seems perfectly possible to me that the present plant life can strike one as pale when seen up close, but their underlying green visible en masse from a distance. But only science fiction readers would worry about rationalizing such a cool effect ;) Anyway, there are plenty of descriptions of "green" greenery in BOTNS, plus heat and humidity in the "true jungle at the waist of the world", so insolation hasn't dropped that much. David Duffy

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net