Urth Net

Index · 2 messages · 2 voices · 15 Dec 2010

(no subject)

Download this conversation
Lee Berman15 Dec 2010, 12:14as archived
(no subject)
↰ answers Matthew Weber · by quotation
5 quoted lines
Lee Berman- But The Green Man is a significant alternate name for the pagan horned god, Great God Pan, etc. Is Wolfe suggesting this is the ultimate and true, unified god of Briah?
Matthew Weber- I really can't see how the text is suggesting such a thing any more than it's suggesting that Jonas is the ultimate and true, unified god of Briah. Happy to reconsider if I'm missing something, of course.
What I mean is that after the massive plot contortions and planetary upheavals, at the end of the story on Ushas we are not left with much of anything that suggests a Christian outcome. No monotheism, no Savior. Instead we have 4 gods derived from human sources, two male, two female, two light, two dark. Plus a demon in the ocean. And a pagan symbol (Green Man) as the marker for this particular future.
Son of Witz15 Dec 2010, 19:35as archived
↳ in reply to Lee Berman
11 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
On Dec 15, 2010, at 4:14 AM, Lee Berman <severiansola at hotmail.com> wrote:
Lee Berman- But The Green Man is a significant alternate name for the pagan horned god, Great God Pan, etc. Is Wolfe suggesting this is the ultimate and true, unified god of Briah?
Matthew Weber- I really can't see how the text is suggesting such a thing any more than it's suggesting that Jonas is the ultimate and true, unified god of Briah. Happy to reconsider if I'm missing something, of course.
What I mean is that after the massive plot contortions and planetary upheavals, at the end of the story on Ushas we are not left with much of anything that suggests a Christian outcome. No monotheism, no Savior. Instead we have 4 gods derived from human sources, two male, two female, two light, two dark. Plus a demon in the ocean. And a pagan symbol (Green Man) as the marker for this particular future.
The map is not the territory. The inhabitants' cosmology is a map. It may not accuratley reflect their world.

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net