Urth Net

Index · 5 messages · 3 voices · 19 Jan 2011

Appearance of the Gods

Download this conversation
Lee Berman19 Jan 2011, 01:42as archived
Appearance of the Gods
1 quoted line
Gerry Quinn: how do you explain Echidna's apparently total lack of acknowledgement that she was speaking to a clone of Typhon
This question raised another, possibly related question in my mind. Pas appears as two-headed in the window. Kypris is a beauty. Echidna is snake-haired I think. Scylla, snakey too? So my question is, why? Why do they look like that? I don't have a clear answer in mind so I was interested in the opinions of others.
James Wynn19 Jan 2011, 13:41as archived
↳ in reply to Lee Berman
5 quoted lines
Lee Berman- Pas appears as two-headed in the window. Kypris is a beauty. Echidna is snake-haired I think. Scylla, snakey too? So my question is, why? Why do they look like that? I don't have a clear answer in mind so I was interested in the opinions of others.
Are you looking for practical reasons? I'm not sure there are any. To some extent, they draw their appearance from monsters whose name they bear, but not especially. To a large extent, there's a tip of the hat to the Olympians they parallel. As as demonic version of Hera, Echidna is associated with the Python that encircles the Earth. Molpe, the demonic Athene, is crazy as opposed to wise and is more a version of the gorgon whose stretched out face embellished Athene's shield. Scylla is the demonic Poseidon and very similar to the Storm King. Actually, Scylla does have a practical reason for her looks. She's a follower of the Megatherian Scylla, and I guess chooses her appearance based on that.
Gerry Quinn19 Jan 2011, 14:07as archived
↳ in reply to James Wynn
9 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
From: "James Wynn" <crushtv at gmail.com> Lee Berman- Pas appears as two-headed in the window. Kypris is a beauty. Echidna is snake-haired I think. Scylla, snakey too? So my question is, why? Why do they look like that? I don't have a clear answer in mind so I was interested in the opinions of others.
Are you looking for practical reasons? I'm not sure there are any. To some extent, they draw their appearance from monsters whose name they bear, but not especially. To a large extent, there's a tip of the hat to the Olympians they parallel. As as demonic version of Hera, Echidna is associated with the Python that encircles the Earth. Molpe, the demonic Athene, is crazy as opposed to wise and is more a version of the gorgon whose stretched out face embellished Athene's shield. Scylla is the demonic Poseidon and very similar to the Storm King. Actually, Scylla does have a practical reason for her looks. She's a follower of the Megatherian Scylla, and I guess chooses her appearance based on that.
Tartaros tells Auk that their appearances are the self-images of the gods. He gives the specific example of Kypris: "You say that you could nearly make out the face of my father's concubine. The face you nearly saw was her own image of herself as she imagines that self to appear. I feel confident that it was a beautiful face. I have never met any woman more secure in her own vanity." - Gerry Quinn
James Wynn19 Jan 2011, 14:15as archived
↳ in reply to Gerry Quinn
4 quoted lines
On 1/19/2011 8:07 AM, Gerry Quinn wrote: Tartaros tells Auk that their appearances are the self-images of the gods. He gives the specific example of Kypris: "You say that you could nearly make out the face of my father's concubine. The face you nearly saw was her own image of herself as she imagines that self to appear. I feel confident that it was a beautiful face. I have never met any woman more secure in her own vanity."
Tartaros' assertion requires serious finessing. One cannot possibly assume that Echidna and Scylla thought they looked like that.
Lee Berman19 Jan 2011, 20:34as archived
↳ follows James Wynn · by subject
4 quoted lines
James Wynn: Are you looking for practical reasons? I'm not sure there are any. To some extent, they draw their appearance from monsters whose name they bear, but not especially..... Actually, Scylla does have a practical reason for her looks. She's a follower of the Megatherian Scylla, and I guess chooses her appearance based on that.
Yes, my question pertained to practical reasons. Even if there is debate on the original appearance of this family (I tend to think Cilinia gave rise to great Scylla), the question is framed by Gerry and your later comments.
2 quoted lines
Gerry Quinn: Tartaros tells Auk that their appearances are the self-images of the gods. He gives the specific example of Kypris
James Wynn: Tartaros' assertion requires serious finessing. One cannot possibly assume that Echidna and Scylla thought they looked like that.
So that's the problem. Even if they really were monsters in their original form, why would they choose monster forms to appear to people in the Whorl? To scare them? We don't see fat Phaea the pig's image on a screen but I suspect it wasn't really scary. I'd hate to think it was pure auctorial choice...he had Typhon as mythological father of all monsters so he felt compelled to name Typhon's family by those names....
1 quoted line
Antonio Pedro Marques: I think the default assumption is that Pas looks like Typhon. People have asked about other gods forgetting that it's Pas who called the shots. If he wanted one of his family to look like a mouse, that's what they would have looked like.
I think this is getting at the inkling I have. Who would have the greatest tendency to think of Kypris as beautiful and the family of Typhon as nasty monsters? As Tartaros, suggests, that would be Kypris herself. Is there any way she could establish enough of her own control over the Whorl to force her own names and her own visions on Typhon's family? If not, perhaps the next best explanation is that it was Pas under the spell of Kypris who gave his family monster names and images. We know there was eternal conflict in Mainframe over control of things. Perhaps Typhon felt compelled to put both his family and Kypris onto the Whorl but once there, Kypris had a much greater influence over Pas than she did as a flesh and blood woman over Typhon. You know, if some tart took over and gave me and my Mom a monster name and a monster face while operating under the protection of my Dad, I might consider killing Dad and hunting down Kypris myself.

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net