Did Pig Kill Silk?Whorl

Well, Borski has sure done a job for us. But I have one question: Pig says he killed an augur. Okay. But "Silk" is very much alive, as he knows as well as anyone. Thus, it does not appear to me that he could believe that he had killed Silk. I should think he would say, "I tried to kill an augur." I guess it also seems to me that Pig would have done a more thorough job. A bunch of cuts on the arms is not a good killing job. A beheading, or a thrust through the heart would be better. Of course, on your thesis, Silk had to be able to "revive," so "Tartaros" had to kill him in a rather "indirect" way. But my first question still stands. Untie this knot for me. Patera Nutria *This is WHORL, for discussion of Gene Wolfe's Book of the Long Sun.

Well, Borski has sure done a job for us. But I have one question: Pig says he killed an augur. Okay. But "Silk" is very much alive, as he knows as well as anyone. Thus, it does not appear to me that he could believe that he had killed Silk. I should think he would say, "I tried to kill an augur." I guess it also seems to me that Pig would have done a more thorough job. A bunch of cuts on the arms is not a good killing job. A beheading, or a thrust through the heart would be better. Of course, on your thesis, Silk had to be able to "revive," so "Tartaros" had to kill him in a rather "indirect" way. But my first question still stands. Untie this knot for me. Patera Nutria *This is WHORL, for discussion of Gene Wolfe's Book of the Long Sun.