Urth Net

Index · 2 messages · 2 voices · 17 May – 18 May 2001

Digest urth.v030.n114

Download this conversation
Dan'l Danehy-Oakes17 May 2001, 15:54originalas archived
Digest urth.v030.n114
↰ answers Michael Andre-Driussi · by quotation
2 quoted lines
Mantis wrote: Jane Doe as Lilith is a very strong thread, agreed.
Don't like it, but have to agree. (Side note -- Lilith is often identified with the Greek snake-women, lamiae, which adds flavor to this.)
1 quoted line
Okay. So the NP beams a copperhead and Jane Doe rises up.
Right.
1 quoted line
Realistically it doesn't make any sense
Realistically, none of this makes sense...
1 quoted line
Meanwhile, there is the repeated trouble in Spokane. That and the question of "how long to the next election," these are the points that sound like "National Crisis" to me.
I can't help thinking you're seeing what you want to see there -- indications of crisis are ambiguous at best; I suspect that, if there's a crisis going on, it's only a crisis for the NP, not for the whole country. I certainly think you're reading-into the conversation with the security guy.
4 quoted lines
And Roy wrote: Do we get a replay of the Eden story, the same way we got a Second Flood in the Urth Cycle? Does that make sense, from a Christian point of view?
I think a good analogy here is to the Narnia books -- it isn't a "replay," but, if God made multiple worlds, how things might play themselves out, differently but according to the old patterns, in those worlds. Like those, I don't think Wolfe writes to be taken allegorically, but perhaps symbolically.
Michael Straight18 May 2001, 08:26originalas archived
↳ follows Dan'l Danehy-Oakes · by subject
5 quoted lines · 1–2 deep
On Thu, 17 May 2001, Dan'l Danehy-Oakes wrote: Do we get a replay of the Eden story, the same way we got a Second Flood in the Urth Cycle? Does that make sense, from a Christian point of view?
I think a good analogy here is to the Narnia books -- it isn't a "replay," but, if God made multiple worlds, how things might play themselves out, differently but according to the old patterns, in those worlds. Like those, I don't think Wolfe writes to be taken allegorically, but perhaps symbolically.
Better yet, Lewis's Perelandra, in which a human from Earth becomes the agent of evil attempting to orchestrate a second fall on the Edenic Venus. I like the idea that, disasterous as Lilith is running amok in our world, the NP, a fallen human, would be a worse threat to unfallen Eden. (But it only works if Lilith is not talking about Cain and Abel after all.) -Rostrum

An unofficial mirror of a public mailing list · about & removal requests · download the archive · before the list · original archive at urth.net